Ashley Moody (R*) vs. Angie Nixon; Byron Donalds (R) vs. David Jolly (D)
I. The Races
U.S. Senate

Ashley Moody (Republican) was appointed to replace Marco Rubio in the United States Senate after he (Rubio) became Secretary of State under Trump 47. Moody had previously been Florida’s Attorney General, most recently winning her second term by +21.2% in 2022. She now faces a special election required by state law.
Angie Nixon (Democrat) is a DSA-aligned politician with three terms in the Florida House of Representatives. She shocked everyone by winning the Democrat nomination against Alexander Vindman in the August primary.
Governor

Byron Donalds (Republican) is the GOP nominee for governor after serving three terms in the U.S. House representing FL-19 (southwestern Florida). He is seeking to continue the reforms of Governor Ron DeSantis, under whom Florida has transformed into a powerful red state.
David Jolly (Democrat) is the latest former Republican to turn Democrat and seek the governorship, following Charlie Crist. Crist lost a close election to Rick Scott in 2014, and was absolutely annihilated by DeSantis in 2022. Strangely enough, Jolly served parts of two terms in the old FL-13, before being ousted by Crist in 2016.
II. State Profile

Most Captain K’s Corner readers remember Florida as an absolutely vital presidential swing state with a GOP-lean for statewide offices. Florida was so critical for Republican hopes that no GOP nominee for president made it to the White House without carrying Florida since 1924. Thanks to the rise of Donald Trump, and the governorship of Ron DeSantis, the days of Florida as a bellwether and swing state are long gone.

Florida is more than R+11% by registration, won by Trump at a margin of 13.1% in 2024, and receives new movers who are reported to be R+40% in their partisan disposition. Combined with the realignment of the Latino voting coalitions (primarily Venezuelan, Cuban, and Puerto Rican in Florida), the Sunshine State is a near-impenetrable red fortress. Republicans, unlike their timid counterparts in Texas, have been viciously attacking Democrat strongholds, and in several instances are turning them red.
Key Statistics
51.5% White, 26.5% Hispanic, 15.1% Black
III. Market Assessment
Polymarket bettors have better vibes about Moody’s campaign against Nixon, but Donalds is also heavily favored to win the governorship.
IV. History
U.S. Senate
Past statewide races and partisan trends are typically useful guides for races like these, but Florida has become so red, the distant past resembles another state entirely. The state hasn’t had two Democrat U.S. Senators serving simultaneously since Bob Graham and Bill Nelson served simultaneously from 2001 to 2005, when Graham retired. Mel Martinez (Republican) was elected in 2004 to replace Graham, but resigned before his term was over and was replaced by George LeMieux, who finished the term and gave way to Marco Rubio.
Rubio served until his appointment to Secretary of State, winning reelection on two more occasions. In that span, Nelson was ousted by Rick Scott in a 2018 upset. Since 2019, Florida has been represented by two Republicans in the U.S. Senate and has seen their reelection margins increase drastically.
Governor
Despite its swing state status, Florida has preferred Republican governors exclusively dating back to the end of the 20th century, when Jeb Bush was elected (1998). Bush was reelected in 2002, then gave way to Crist in 2006. Crist vacated the office in 2010 and was replaced by Scott, who won harrowing margins of +1.2% in 2010 and +1.1% in 2014 to keep the streak alive. Perhaps the most important gubernatorial win of the century occurred in 2018, when DeSantis defied the polling odds and inched past Andrew Gillum:

Florida was less than 33,000 Democrat votes away from electing a drug addict living a reckless lifestyle instead of the governor who turned them into the next Texas. DeSantis had been without hope until Trump endorsed his candidacy, and then overcame absolutely clueless polling to beat Gillum:

Since the modern Florida GOP made it out of the stormy waters, it has been smooth sailing.
V. Analysis of 2026 Primary Results
U.S. Senate
Moody took on a few primary challengers, but won her primary with 79.6% of the vote. The real primary drama took place over on the Democrat side, when Nixon stunned Vindman:

If you’re sitting around worried about what a bunch of polls say, the one poll I found on the Democrat primary had Vindman up by 10.0%. He lost by almost 12 points. Vindman, logically speaking, is a hated figure in Florida because of his role in targeting President Trump – the Republican leader at the time of Florida’s ascent to red stronghold.

While no one disputes the legitimacy of Nixon’s primary victory, her radicalism and ties to DSA-aligned groups will alienate the moderate baby boomers who supported Vindman and voted for Joe Biden in 2020.
Governor

In a crowded field full of big names, including the sitting Lieutenant Governor (Collins) and former speaker of the Florida House of Representatives (Renner), as well as an insurgent fanning the flames of Gen Z resentment (Fishback), Donalds rode Trump’s endorsement to a comfortable win. While Donalds has his detractors, DeSantis is now behind his campaign and he shouldn’t be missing any key GOP coalition.

Jolly won an easy majority in another crowded field, and there is no reported Democrat drama surrounding his win.
VI. Polls
U.S. Senate

The RCP average of polls has Moody up 7, although St. Pete Polls is sandbagging her a bit with their recent +2.
Governor

With fewer polls making up the gubernatorial average, Donalds is up 5. Like Moody’s race, he’s held down a notch by St. Pete Polls. Notably, both Moody and Donalds are +11 in the most recent Stetson University poll.
VII. Media Ratings
U.S. Senate

None of the major reviewing bodies think Moody is in any trouble.
Governor

While none of them have Donalds on the hot seat, they’re leaving the window open for Jolly to close the gap.
VIII. Party Registration

What’s the biggest mountain in the way of the Nixon/Jolly pairing? Look no further than party registration. Remember when I mentioned that new transplants to Florida are reportedly R+40% in their partisanship? The numbers above seemingly confirm this.
Republicans have netted a gain of 439,197 voters since Trump carried the state by 13.1% less than two years ago. Nearly 300,000 of that net is from Democrat losses, but still roughly 140,000 of that comes from new GOP registrations. These gains are widespread, reaching all the way down to former Democrat strongholds in Miami. Florida’s transformation is truly astounding.
IX. Election Considerations
People frequently ask me which states have made the most important reforms to elections since the 2020 quasi election. “Florida” is my hands-down answer. Governor DeSantis signed Senate Bill 524 in 2022, creating the election crimes task force and ensuring that the state would have proper control over mail-in balloting (requiring voters to request a ballot and confirm the address the ballot would be sent to). While it is a large state full of opportunities to attempt fraud, it has done an incredible job at preventing mass fraud.
Notably, Florida sets the “gold standard” for counting millions of ballots, nearly the entire statewide count, by the time people wake up the next day. They learned how important public trust in elections is after the 2000 “hanging chads” debacle and have set the standard for the rest of the country.
X. Summary and Election Estimate
Florida is already running to the right of its final 2024 mail balloting return splits, and now the fake pollsters are quietly moving away from the Sunshine State. These two elections aren’t coming down to “who” will win, but by how much the Republican candidates will win by. The decision matrices tell the tale:
U.S. Senate

Governor

Thanks to Florida’s efforts to secure elections, the overwhelming growth of the Republican coalition, and a national atmosphere that has soured on the Democrat brand, these are two of the most obvious predictions out there.
Forecast for FL U.S. Senate

My 99/1 rating for Moody is to essentially state that I see zero path for Nixon. It wouldn’t surprise me if Moody, thanks to Nixon’s insane radicalism, wins by more than 20 points. The bigger question I have is whether or not Moody will win every county.
Forecast for FL Governor

Donalds is also essentially a lock. To believe Floridians would watch the state clear R+11% by registration and even think about handing the keys over to the party they’ve completely abandoned defies logic. Donalds won’t have Moody’s numbers because Jolly is at least a real candidate, but I’d expect a margin in at least the low double digits.
Florida is a unique phenomenon, and we should all invite Democrats to waste funds there.
Seth Keshel, MBA is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy and a retired Army Captain. He publishes Captain K’s Corner on Substack.