Restoring National Sovereignty Across Europe

National flags of European countries displayed at a European building, symbolizing sovereignty and national identity

Change will not come if we wait for someone else, or if we delay for another time. The words of Barack Obama, spoken during his historic campaign in 2008, still resonate—but today, they carry a very different meaning. It is a rallying cry for patriots, conservatives, and all who believe in freedom, sovereignty, and the dignity of our nations to stand together. We are the ones we’ve been waiting for. We are the change that we seek.

In 2008, Obama’s words signaled the dawn of a new era: one marked by social justice campaigns and the rise of “wokeism.” For years, these ideas were cloaked in promises of progress and inclusivity.

But what have they truly delivered? Today, we see the devastating consequences—fractured societies, eroded national identities, and an alarming loss of freedoms.

But, the tide is turning. The reelection of President Trump has sent a clear and powerful message from the people of the United States. The message is simple: We want our country back.

We want to be proud of our flag, our culture, and our heritage. We demand affordable, reliable energy to power our homes and businesses. We seek real food from our farmers, not synthetic substitutes dictated by unelected technocrats. We want secured borders, prosperity, peace, and the ability to pursue happiness without interference.

The overwhelming MAGA victory—President Trump reclaiming the presidency, the Senate, the House, and the popular vote—reflects a mandate that can not be ignored

For too long, the radical left has sought to dismantle the pillars of our civilization. Obama’s policies, often presented as ‘progress’, initiated a chain of events with devastating effects. I’ll give you four examples:

  • The Arab Spring, spurred by social media campaigns, unleashed waves of instability that flooded Europe with millions of migrants. Our historic continent—once a beacon of cultural and intellectual achievements—is now grappling with security threats and the erosion of its identity and culture.
  • The war in Ukraine, provoked by Obama’s NeoCon allies, has brought untold suffering. It began with the removal of Ukraine’s democratically elected leader in 2014, setting the stage for conflict. These NeoCons, in collusion with the Military-Industrial Complex, are as culpable as any aggressor.
  • Critical Race Theory, a twisted ideology. It is nothing short of racism repackaged, weaponized to pit communities against each other.
  • Censorship and suppression of free speech. Through NGOs and the so-called “Censorship Industrial Complex,” they controlled narratives and silenced dissenting voices.

Their strategy has always been sophisticated—using fear, globalist policies, the illusion of moral superiority, and ‘democracy’ of institutions instead of democracy of the people.

The United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals, the Green Deal, and the WHO’s pandemic overreach are all symptoms of a broader agenda: a transfer of power from the people to unaccountable elites.

Even NATO, once a coalition of nations united against foreign aggression, has now also become a tool wielded to suppress populist movements among its own people.

But we are not powerless. We the People represent true democracy. If we unite, we can reverse this destructive course. The momentum of the MAGA movement can inspire change across Europe and beyond. Now is the time to build a unified front that transcends party lines and minor disagreements.

We must Make Europe Great Again by:

  • Restoring Free Speech: Reverse the Digital Services Act and protect public discourse.
  • Ensuring Freedom: No Central Bank Digital Currencies. No digital IDs. We are born free and do not need technocratic controls.
  • Dismantling the Green Deal: End this social engineering project that sacrifices our economies and energy and food security for an illusion of environmental progress.
  • Defending Our Borders: Protect our nations from uncontrolled migration that threatens both safety and cultural heritage. National civil rights must take precedence over globalist human rights.
  • Exposing Corruption: Demand full transparency in dealings with corporations and NGOs.
  • Deregulating Economies: Empower small and medium-sized businesses—the backbone of our prosperity. Deregulation fuels innovation and competitiveness.
  • Restoring National Sovereignty: Renegotiate or cancel harmful international agreements and treaties.

Change will not come if we wait for someone else or another time. We are the ones we’ve been waiting for. We are the change that we seek. Obama’s words, once a banner for radical policies, now serve as a call to reverse the damage inflicted on our nations and it’s people.

Let us unite, work together, and make this a reality. Let us Make Europe Great Again.

Friedrich Merz Puts Germany’s Election Into Overdrive

Close-up of German election ballot envelopes for the Bundestag election

(This article was written by Derk Jan Eppink and appeared in Wynia’s Week. Friedrich Merz brengt Duitse verkiezingen in stroomversnelling)

The temperature in the run-up to the German Bundestag elections on 23 February rose to boiling point after a 28-year-old Afghan attacked a toddlers’ class in Aschaffenburg (Bavaria) with a knife. He killed a 2-year-old boy, as well as a 41-year-old man who came to the child’s aid. Opposition leader Friedrich Merz, chancellor candidate of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU/CSU), will on Thursday launch a five-point plan in the Bundestag that tightens migration policy to an unprecedented degree. In doing so, Merz said, votes from the Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) are also ‘welcome’. The game is on.

Merz presents his five-point plan as the basis for legislation on which the Bundestag must vote. Left-wing parties such as the social democratic SPD and the Greens recoil from Merz’s hard intervention. They accuse him of demolishing the cordon sanitaire, in German jargon ‘die Brandmauer’, against the AfD. Until now the votes of AfD members of the Bundestag were ignored by the coalition of social democrats, greens and liberals, and also by the opposition group of the CDU/CSU. Merz is now seeking support ‘from whoever’.

Until recently the campaign for the Bundestag elections rippled along quietly. The theme was mainly energy and climate policy, on which Germany has cut its own fingers, above all through the abolition of nuclear energy. Aschaffenburg became the turning point, once again a ‘Zeitenwende’, and Merz, who had not really come into his own yet, occupied the epicentre of the political debate with his five-point plan. He argues for:

  • Permanent controls of the German borders with the nine neighbouring countries;
  • Immediate expulsion of foreigners who enter Germany without valid travel documents;
  • Asylum seekers whose application is rejected may not move about freely but must go into detention;
  • More support for the federal states in carrying out the obligation to expel;
  • Strict rules for foreigners who have committed criminal offences, or who are ‘dangerous’ (unstable); they are placed in pre-departure detention, if necessary for an indefinite period.

Merz maintains that his five-point plan is in accordance with European law because the European system is currently ‘dysfunctional’. Just look at the Dublin Regulation (2013) that obliges asylum seekers to file their asylum request in the country of arrival. Most of them, however, want to go to Germany, and countries on the European external border let them through. Ergo: ‘Germany has the right of self-defence’. In an emergency situation it may apply national law ‘vorrangig anwenden’, because European law is not functioning.

Berlin woke up with a start at this reversal, and opponents of Merz feared he was imitating Trump. A columnist for Welt am Sonntag wrote about ‘wenn Merz den Trump macht’ and predicted: ‘Merz is going to lay claim to Mallorca and the North Sea will become the Gulf of Germany’. Donald Trump is not a popular figure in the land of his forefathers.

Ulf Poschardt, a prominent author at Die Welt, sees Merz’s sprint to the head of the peloton as a stroke of genius. ‘If the CDU takes the migration theme to itself before the elections, what is the AfD needed for?’ According to him many voters vote AfD out of disappointment with the established parties. ‘The offer now comes from “die bürgerliche Mitte”, which says: we have understood, we are putting an end to the idiotic migration policy’. Poschardt is uncommonly sharp, something he may have picked up from his Danish mother.

Merz has used at least one instrument from the Trump handbook: surprise. He comes up with a plan, outpaces the other parties, the media magnify it, and for voters Merz is suddenly at the centre, three weeks before the elections. Where before he was just one of the colourless gnomes, now he is setting the tone and thereby putting other parties on the spot.

In Berlin left-wing demonstrators took to the streets (according to the organisers there were 100,000 participants, according to the police 35,000) against the ‘Rechtsruck’ and against Merz. He was portrayed as the ‘stirrup of fascism’. It was a Berlin carnival procession that will sooner convince Germans ‘in den Ländern’ that Merz is on the right track.

SPD and Greens turned against the five-point plan on account of the ‘Brandmauer’, the total exclusion of the AfD in every way. In the Bundestag too, as with the agreement between the coalition and opposition parties never to let the votes of AfD parliamentarians be decisive. A proposal that wins the AfD’s approval must by definition be voted down. To that Merz is now making an exception. ‘I am sticking to that’, he said on Sunday to ZDF. Merz does, however, still refuse a coalition with the AfD. He wants to make that party ‘superfluous’ by taking up the grievances of the voters.

The AfD’s biggest supporter at the moment is Elon Musk, the richest man in the world. Whether it helps the AfD is doubtful. Anti-Americanism lives below the surface in West Germany; in East Germany it is virulent.

A vote on the five-point plan, which Merz wants to pilot through the Bundestag unchanged, puts all the other parties under pressure. Left-wing parties (SPD, Greens) form the front of refusal. The Bündnis Sarah Wagenknecht (BSW) is hesitating. The liberal FDP appears to be against. That is risky, because the FDP is hovering around the 5 percent electoral threshold in the polls. And then the AfD. If that party votes against, it is voting against its own policy programme. The parliamentarians of CDU/CSU, FDP, AfD and possibly BSW together add up to a majority. With his proposal Merz is driving all the other parties before him.

Merz’s initiative cannot be seen apart from his closest adviser and secretary-general of the CDU, Carsten Linnemann (47) from Paderborn, a municipality in North Rhine-Westphalia. Linnemann speaks briefly and clearly and thinks in strategic terms, whereas Merz, who comes from the Sauerland, still has a tendency now and then to misspeak. He often talks too fast. It is plausible that Linnemann is the architect of this operation, in which Merz was brought into line with the Bavarian CSU leader Markus Söder. Linnemann appeared in the media as the spokesman for the proposal; Merz initially made only the official speeches.

Linnemann, the son of a bookseller, is a rising star in the party and has been a member of the Bundestag since 2009, elected thanks to a Direktmandat. He is economically liberal and socially a values conservative. During the euro crisis he voted against all the financial packages to rescue Greece. He is fiscally conservative and wanted to abolish the ‘Solidarity Tax’ of 1991 (for aid to East Germany) in 2021, because this ‘temporary’ levy simply kept going. In 2017 he argued for an ‘Islam law’ to establish the rights and duties of Muslim organisations, such as a ban on the full financing of mosques from abroad.

Linnemann defends the five-point plan with unprecedented steadfastness. ‘We are not going to enter a coalition if this plan is rejected’. With that he keeps the CDU/CSU proposal, and the possible wriggling of the AfD, sharply on the voter’s radar.

The series of violence against citizens in Mannheim, Solingen, Magdeburg and Aschaffen. Merkel has made only one appearance during the election campaign: at the CDU’s New Year reception in North Rhine-Westphalia, where Hendrik Wüst is minister-president. Symbolic, because Wüst is a critic of the CDU’s ‘right-wing policy’, and a ‘Merkellian’. He will have to keep quiet for now, because it is the voter who decides on Merz and his plans. If Merz wins on 23 February, he will be the next chancellor. If the gamble fails, Wüst will undoubtedly be standing in the line of succession.

Derk Jan Eppink is a Distinguished Fellow (Honorary) at the Gold Institute for International Strategy, a Washington D.C.-based foreign policy and defense think tank.

Op-Ed: Muslim Americans Could Be Key Addition to the MAGA Movement

A group of diverse individuals standing in front of an American flag

(This article was written by Adelle Nazarian and appeared in The Western Journal. Op-Ed: Muslim Americans Could Be Key Addition to the MAGA Movement)

The year began with a stark reminder of the challenges facing America. A shocking terror attack in New Orleans, perpetrated by an American-born extremist, underscored the persistent threat of radical ideologies.

Despite former President Trump’s decisive actions against and defeat of ISIS during his first term, the specter of extremism has not been eradicated as the group’s radical ideas continue to spread.

Predictably, some far-right pundits wasted no time in casting a wide net of blame, targeting an entire religion and calling for a draconian crackdown on mosques. While such sweeping generalizations are counterproductive, it’s equally critical to scrutinize the role of organizations like the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR).

Although CAIR swiftly condemned the New Orleans attacker, the organization’s track record raises questions. Its past associations and controversial statements have often drawn criticism from those who view it as more focused on political agendas than meaningful reform.

This tension underscores a broader challenge: how to foster a transformative alliance between Muslim Americans and the MAGA movement without ignoring the complexities within Muslim leadership structures. In this effort, groups like the Muslim American Leadership Alliance (MALA) stand out as key allies for the Trump administration.

MALA has consistently demonstrated a commitment to promoting pluralism, individual freedom, and a constructive dialogue that bridges divides. Their emphasis on empowering Muslim Americans to engage in civic and political life aligns naturally with the MAGA movement’s vision for a revitalized and united America.

Groups like the International Quranic Center (IQC), the Islamic Supreme Council of America (ISCA) and the American Islamic Forum for Democracy have also been critical of CAIR, accusing it of promoting Islamist agendas and failing to represent the diversity of Muslim-American viewpoints.

Additionally, figures like Special Presidential Envoy for Special Missions Richard Grenell have played a pivotal role in building this coalition. Leading up the election, through Arab Americans for Trump, recognizable by their tagline “Yalla,” Grenell worked to unite Arabs, Muslims, and Middle Eastern Christians, particularly in Michigan.

This electorate proved crucial in Trump’s victory, flipping a traditionally blue state red and showcasing the political strength of such alliances.

This is a breakthrough for the Republican Party and should not be taken lightly. Now is the time for MAGA to foster and cultivate the relationship with Muslim Americans and bring them back to the Republican Party which is where the majority of them roosted prior to 9/11.

Muslim Americans: An Unexpected but Natural Ally

In the 2020 election, 21 percent of Muslim voters cast their ballots for Trump, surpassing support for Vice President Kamala Harris. This was not a statistical anomaly; it was a reaction to the Democratic Party’s repeated failures.

Under Democratic leadership, anti-Muslim hate crimes surged by 70 percent in just six months. Sacred spaces were desecrated, Muslim-owned businesses destroyed in riots, and communities were left with hollow promises instead of real solutions.

President Biden’s “National Strategy to Counter Islamophobia and Anti-Arab Hate” was too little, too late. It read more like a hasty attempt to placate than a substantive plan. Discontent reached a boiling point during the Gaza conflict, where Biden’s handling drew sharp criticism from CAIR and drove his disapproval among Muslim Americans to a staggering 98 percent.

Contrast this with Trump’s policies, which resonate deeply with the conservative values held by many Muslim Americans. Limited government, strong family structures, economic empowerment, and a commitment to ending endless wars—these principles align with the aspirations of Muslim immigrants seeking to preserve their faith and the American Dream.

Trump’s efforts to broker peace in the Middle East earned him respect long before the idea of a Gaza ceasefire became remotely plausible.

And make no mistake, Hamas has agreed to return the remaining hostages because of Trump. Sadly, the majority of those hostages are no longer thought to be alive.

A Shared Vision for America’s Future

This alliance is about more than politics; it’s about preserving the pillars of faith, family, and freedom. And it has the potential to reshape American politics. Muslim Americans and MAGA supporters share a desire to resist destructive ideologies, protect traditional families while resisting attacks on them, defend unborn lives, and uphold religious liberty.

They envision an education system that prioritizes learning over indoctrination and a society where the next generation can thrive.

However, this partnership requires significant changes on both sides. Muslim Americans must critically evaluate their historical loyalty to the Democratic Party, which has often taken their votes for granted.

The MAGA movement, for its part, must confront and reject the Islamophobic rhetoric that has alienated potential allies. Before 9/11’s surge in anti-Muslim sentiment, Muslim voters were a reliable Republican constituency. A return to this shared history is not only possible but necessary for America’s future.

The Path Forward

The stakes have never been higher. America is at a crossroads, and the opportunity to unite diverse communities under the banner of shared values cannot be squandered.

For the MAGA movement, forging a genuine partnership with Muslim Americans is not just strategic; it is a moral imperative. By focusing on common ground and fostering mutual respect, this alliance can rebuild communities, restore moral foundations, and chart a path toward national renewal.

With faith, family, and freedom at its core, this coalition has the power to heal a divided nation. Together, Muslim Americans, organizations like MALA, Arab Americans for Trump, and MAGA supporters can seize this final chance to make America whole again.

Adelle Nazarian is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy, a Washington D.C.-based foreign policy and defense think tank.

The Road of Hammer Blows

Corner tower of the Reichstag building in Berlin

(This article was written by Hermann Tertsch and appeared in El Debate. La senda de los mazazos)

The European People’s Party is on edge for many reasons. The first is, of course, the panic of its German component, the CDU/CSU, which is heading with an already failed candidate into an election it believed it had won hands down and which is approaching on 23 February like a nightmare. The CDU believed it could keep a good grip on the situation created by the fall of the three-party government of socialists, greens and liberals, the worst government in the history of the Federal Republic, which has brutally aggravated the already very precarious situation of all these years of social democratic and green consensus under Angela Merkel, a chancellor who has in the end turned out to be, and few apart from her now dispute it, a curse for Germany and for Europe.

In any case, Friedrich Merz has shown himself to be as weak now as he was when Merkel crushed him as a rival in the succession to Helmut Kohl. If, because of the failures of the three-party government of the inept social democrat Olaf Scholz, his party enjoyed a comfortable lead and majority of almost twenty points over the second most voted party, that gap with the second party today is seven points.

What is terrifying for them is that this second party is Alternative for Germany, the only party that has a programme for a change of policy for Germany. Merz would not be worried if the socialists or the greens were closing in on him, because he has already said that he is going to govern with one of those two parties, both increasingly left-wing and both resounding failures. Or with both, if the numbers do not add up. An alliance with the socialists and the greens would bring the same policies as the government that has just collapsed for causing the worst economic, political, social and security crisis Germany has suffered since 1949.

In any case Merz has solemnly announced that he will not make a pact with Alice Weidel, the candidate of the Alternative (AfD), which with its collective leadership has run an excellent campaign, has put the party in order and under discipline, and has not allowed the secret services or the lies of the press to mount another operation against them in a campaign orchestrated by a media landscape even more monolithic and more submissive to the orders of social democratic consensus politics than the Spanish one. That being so, the AfD’s message has been delivered by the CDU itself: if you want change in Germany you have to vote for Alternative for Germany. Because all the others are going to end up governing together, doing the same thing as until now.

If you want a vote to put an end to the incentivised invasion, to open up spaces of freedom and deregulation for people and for businesses, to restore freedom of opinion, to expel from the country those who live in a massively parasitic way and are the protagonists of the main crime and violence, so that common sense is restored as is happening in other countries and especially in the United States, you have no choice but to vote for Alice Weidel. And the CDU’s suicidal message is taking hold, and it is already clear that even if it beats the AfD by a few points and forms a government, when that government dies an ignominious death like the previous one, the AfD will be close to an absolute majority.

Hence the panic in Europe, which takes shape in all kinds of absurdities such as now, in an unprecedented resolution on Venezuela in which the People’s Party members have been left practically alone with Maduro’s accomplices, who are the Spanish socialists.

The People’s Party in Spain is an expert at falling into these traps that now grip all the parties of its group and the CDU in particular. It already allowed itself to be led into a trap by the socialists and by its own fears, complexes and ghosts, a trap that cost Alberto Núñez Feijóo the leadership of the government. That was in that ill-fated July when the soothsayers and the advisers on polls and radio convinced him that he could destroy Vox and keep all its votes for a government on his own. Ambition burst the sack, and that opened the door to the criminal government we have today under Pedro Sánchez.

Beyond the national tragedy of having a government dedicated exclusively to its own survival in power in order to prolong its impunity through the criminal cover-up of its earlier offences, the PP failed in its struggle to destroy Vox. That has come at a high price, because it means the total failure of Feijóo’s in itself pathetic strategy of seeking to destroy the only conservative force in Spain from positions that are increasingly social democratic and close to the left. The hammer blow to the PP that is the unstoppable rise of all the parties to its right, which sooner rather than later will confront it with the existential dilemma of division, has been redoubled by the hammer blow of the victory of Donald Trump, whom they attacked, defamed and despised just as much as the socialists and communists did.

And another simultaneous and terrible hammer blow is the great victory in Austria of the Freedom Party (FPÖ), Vox’s partner in PATRIOTS. After an attempt by the whole consensus brigade to form a government of three parties against the winner of the election, which was the FPÖ, they have had to acknowledge their failure, and the head of state, the sectarian green Alexander Van der Bellen, has had no choice but to comply this time with the constitution and entrust the formation of a government to the FPÖ leader, Herbert Kickl.

Within a few weeks we will foreseeably have in Austria a government in which the FPÖ will be the leader and by far the largest party, and the People’s Party will be the junior partner, which, given the results but above all given the subsequent polls, will have little chance of halting a policy of real change. The FPÖ, which won the election with 28 per cent, is already approaching 40 per cent. The PP keeps falling. This hammer blow from Vienna, like all the others, ought to advise the members of the European People’s Party to reconsider their attitude in the face of their catastrophic results. Since that is not happening, one must assume that they will carry on down this road of hammer blows that they bring upon themselves for having chained their fate to the parties of the left, which are already going down the drain of history.

Hermann Tertsch is a Distinguished Fellow (Honorary) at the Gold Institute for International Strategy, a Washington D.C.-based foreign policy and defense think tank.

With Donald Trump, the Netherlands Gets New Openings at the White House

The White House in Washington, D.C., with gardens and a central fountain

(This article was written by Derk Jan Eppink and appeared in Wynia’s Week. Met Donald Trump krijgt Nederland nieuwe kansen in het Witte Huis)

With the inauguration, this coming Monday, of Donald Trump as the 47th president of the United States, a political and cultural ‘Wende’ begins in world politics. The fault line runs between the pursuit of the ‘national interest’ that Trump espouses and the multilateralism that Europe advocates, with an eye to ‘global governance’.

Trump’s aim is not a ‘Metternichian order’ with a balance of power, as in Europe after the Congress of Vienna (1815), but the ‘Trumpian world order’ with American leadership under the motto ‘America First’. In short: the new ‘Sheriff in Town’.

In Western European ears that sounds like a modern version of the ‘gunboat diplomacy’ that European colonial powers used to impose their will on recalcitrant peoples. Such as Trump’s remarks about the purchase of Greenland, at Denmark’s expense.

For the Danish government that is alarming, an offer they hoped would never come. America has at one time or another bought a sizeable part of its own territory. Such as the ‘Louisiana Purchase’ in 1803, west of the Mississippi, from France. In 1819 America bought eastern Florida from Spain. From tsarist Russia in 1867, the enormous Alaska.

Trump wants Greenland in the shop window. He is already putting pressure on the Danish government, because he does not rule out military intervention. And that toward a fellow NATO member state. The Danish king is giving Greenland a larger place on his coat of arms and Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen says that Greenland is ‘not for sale’. But she leaves the door ajar: ‘It is also important what the inhabitants of Greenland themselves want.’ Suppose there is a referendum and a majority of Greenland’s 56,000 inhabitants accept America as protector. That makes more of an impression than Denmark.

Anyone who looks at the globe from above sees that Greenland, for the Dutch a ‘far away show’, is a large island (six times Germany) between North America and Russia. Strategically important, because it is the flight path of intercontinental missiles. Moreover, of the 34 critical raw materials, 25 are to be found in Greenland. Where there are raw materials, China comes around the corner, and Russia is close by. Trump wants to plant the American flag before it is too late. Geopolitics begins with geography, and power politics is his method.

In his first term Trump was successful in dealing with the ‘bad boys’ of the world order: Russia, China, the Taliban, Iran, North Korea. Vladimir Putin kept quiet. Perhaps Russia would not have invaded Ukraine if Trump had still been president. China has a longer-term goal: to be the strongest power in the world in 2049, one hundred years after the founding of the People’s Republic. The sinologist Michael Pillsbury published a book about it: The Hundred-Year Marathon. China has a strategy: it fills every vacuum unnoticed, however small. The China of Xi Jinping, by now ‘president for life’, exercises patience. At present the country is struggling with a property crisis. The economy is sputtering. Better to wait four years until Trump is gone.

Iran also kept quiet during Trump’s first term. As did the Taliban. America dropped the MOAB (Mother of All Bombs) near their headquarters. When Trump disappeared in 2021, the Taliban went into action again and reconquered Afghanistan. The North Korean potentate, Kim Jong-un, never gave up his nuclear weapons.

With Trump’s return the ‘bad guys’ know what time it is. Trump threatened that ‘all hell will break out’ if Hamas did not release the Israeli hostages before his swearing in. Hamas had understood the message and gave way. Not under pressure from Joe Biden, but through the words of Trump and his draconian threat.

Iran can count on the hard approach. The reign of terror in Tehran that once constructed the ‘axis of resistance’ against Israel, by way of Assad’s Syria, Hezbollah in Lebanon and Hamas in the Gaza Strip, is a ‘sitting duck’. Iranian allies in the Middle East have been liquidated; the relationship with Russia has soured. It is not out of the question that Israel will take out the Iranian nuclear installations, with Trump’s blessing and with precision bombs from America. The disappearance of the ayatollah regime would be a ‘game changer’ in the Middle East. With the Iranian revolution in 1979 the worldwide radicalisation of Islam began, right into the streets of Western Europe.

For quite some time Trump has been promising a peace settlement to end the war in Ukraine within 24 hours. His advisers mention a period of 100 days. It is evident that Europe itself can achieve nothing, apart from sanctions packages that mainly weaken its own economy. Ending the war in Ukraine is a matter for the ‘Great Powers’, such as America and Russia; for the second not because of the economy but because of the possession of 6,500 nuclear warheads. Europe looks like the Austro-Hungarian dual monarchy, a weak entity with a great deal of trumpet music and marching operetta armies.

Europe would do well not to lecture Trump, but to look at what America’s turnaround actually consists of. Trump II is better organised than Trump I. Susie Wiles (67), the first female chief of staff in the White House, holds the reins firmly. Whoever leaks is out. Trump is far more disciplined than before. His ministerial candidates are getting through the Senate hearings fairly easily. If he wants to make the turn to the right durable, he will have to work purposefully for four years.

After his inauguration Trump will launch about a hundred ‘executive orders’, a kind of decree. The border with Mexico will be practically closed. Americans want an end to the flow of illegal immigration, of well over 12 million people during Biden’s presidency. That influx caused enormous problems, above all in large cities, often run by Democrats.

Climate policy is going into the shredder as a ‘green scam’. Trump wants to curb inflation by raising energy production, under the motto ‘drill baby drill’. It is likely that America will leave the Paris Climate Agreement again.

Woke, the contemporary cultural revolution, is being scrapped at the American federal government; many large companies had already done so. It would be good if European countries followed that example. The ‘California model’ went up in flames; Hollywood and its surroundings burned to the ground. That was not attributable to climate change but to ‘progressive mismanagement’: woke personnel policy, irresponsible nature policy and failing water management. ‘Woke’ is ‘broke’.

In reality Trump has only two years. In 2026 come the midterms with the re-election of Congress, where Trump now has narrow majorities. He has to ‘deliver’ in a short time. In the field of foreign policy he has practically a free hand, but domestically the room is limited. He has to steer a tax-cut bill through Congress quickly, and even campaign for it in the districts of recalcitrant party colleagues.

Trump’s view of Europe is limited. His guests at the inauguration are above all conservative and nationalist politicians, such as Tino Chrupalla (AfD), Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, Éric Zemmour (Reconquête) and Tom Van Grieken (Vlaams Belang). A pity that the attendance of Geert Wilders did not work out. Trump sees Europe through the lens of nation states. For him the EU is a regional organisation, like the Organization of American States (OAS). European states can play a larger role, but most are strongly divided internally, Germany and France above all.

The Netherlands gets a chance to raise its profile more strongly in Washington with a ‘right-wing’ cabinet. Doors will open more easily in Trumpian circles. Appropriate emotional intelligence is required, though, by not immediately taking the measure of Americans, above all Trumpists. Begin by listening.

Derk Jan Eppink is a Distinguished Fellow (Honorary) at the Gold Institute for International Strategy, a Washington D.C.-based foreign policy and defense think tank.

Will Austria Get a ‘Volkskanzler’ After All?

Exterior view of the Vienna Parliament Building with the Athena Fountain

(This article was written by Derk Jan Eppink and appeared in Wynia’s Week. Krijgt Oostenrijk dan toch een ‘Volkskanzler’?)

Herbert Kickl (56), leader of the Freiheitliche Partei Österreichs (FPÖ), stands on the threshold of the Bundeskanzleramt in Vienna. He was given the assignment of forming a new Austrian government by President Alexander van der Bellen (80), a Green no less. Austria is going through what the Netherlands went through last year. And for the third time at that.

In the parliamentary elections of 29 September last year, the FPÖ became the largest party in Austria for the first time. Christian Democrats (ÖVP), Socialists (SPÖ) and Liberals (NEOS, in full ‘Das Neue Österreich’) sat down at the table together to keep the ‘Freiheitlichen’ outside the door. After three months it blew up behind closed doors so violently that the formation attempt failed. The Liberals walked away angry because the economic reforms were ‘too thin’. Hard measures were needed, because Austria is exceeding the budget deficit of 3 percent, the European norm. With Socialists, cutting spending is difficult. Christian Democrats and Liberals have a majority of one seat in the Austrian parliament. ‘Unworkable’, they concluded. President Van der Bellen had to knock on the door of the man they all wanted to avoid: Herbert Kickl.

In the Netherlands the PVV became the largest party in 2023. But Geert Wilders did not become prime minister, because a government at arm’s length had to be formed, with the parliamentary group leaders as the school board. Austria does not work that way. Kickl got the bone on his plate and he intends to strip it. Van der Bellen, who hates Kickl and his FPÖ, had no other option. The ÖVP, the only partner that qualifies, faces the same impasse the CDA faced in 2010. The party is internally torn, but the situation is more hopeless than on the previous occasions, in 2000 and 2017. The ÖVP was the largest then and called the shots over its junior partner, the FPÖ.

The roles are now reversed. Kickl read the ÖVP the riot act: ‘No games, no tricks, no sabotage and no obstruction. Otherwise there will be new elections and we are ready for them.’ ‘Neuwahlen’ are a nightmare for the Christian Democrats, because according to opinion polls the FPÖ would grow even larger and the ÖVP shrink even further.

In 2000 the ÖVP, with Chancellor Wolfgang Schüssel, was still lord and master. The FPÖ, then led by Jörg Haider, had to bow. He himself took no seat in the government. He bombarded it from the outside, quarrelled at home and eventually left his party to found a new one. In 2008 he was killed in a car crash, heavily under the influence. Politically speaking, Haider was an eternal adolescent. Because of the split, the FPÖ sank in the polls. Although Kickl, like Haider, came from Carinthia and was his pupil, he did not follow the ‘Obmann’ in his split.

In 2017 the FPÖ grew like wildfire again because of the migration crisis. The party, by then led by Heinz-Christian Strache, was needed once more. This time it was the young ÖVP politician and chancellor candidate Sebastian Kurz (38) who came knocking. It clicked with Vice-Chancellor Strache, and Kickl became interior minister. In 2019 Strache’s career went into a nosedive because of the Ibiza video, which, and the timing was good, had been secretly recorded two years earlier. The party leader, then still in opposition, discussed proposals with a woman who presented herself as the niece of a Russian oligarch. It concerned a ‘deal’ cum ‘dirty trick’ not unusual in Austria, whereby government contracts are awarded in exchange for positive publicity. Strache resigned, Kickl was dismissed on the spot by Kurz, and after that the remaining FPÖ ministers left as well. The party fell into a deep hole again.

The new leader of the FPÖ became… Herbert Kickl. At first sight not a charismatic figure. A small build, and too ascetic for a party where the beer flows abundantly, as in the bygone days of the ‘Burschenschaften’, student associations with a national-conservative character.

Kickl rebuilt the party from the ruins, and received a gift while doing so: covid. He painted government policy, including vaccinations and lockdowns, as an ‘attack on freedom’. He presented himself as the future ‘Volkskanzler’, which immediately set off alarm bells among opponents. Was there not also that other Austrian, A. Hitler, who once proclaimed the same? Kickl said he wanted to present himself as the chancellor ‘für den kleinen Mann’, in order to protect him against ‘Staatsgewalt’ and against the immigrating outside world. Austria was to become ‘eine Festung’. Kickl himself does not come across as a tribune of the people. He speaks with sharp formulations, purposefully and in a calm tone. No blustering torrent of words.

After the swearing in of those elected, the Austrian parliament became a bastion of the FPÖ, which supplied the speaker in Walter Rosenkranz, the highest office of the Republic after the president. With 57 members, of whom 13 women, the FPÖ group became the largest. Rosenkranz struck at once with his first foreign guest: Viktor Orbán, the prime minister of Hungary. As if the Austro-Hungarian dual monarchy (1867-1918) were making its re-entry. The speaker had the European flag removed from the reception salon and invited no parliamentary groups other than the FPÖ. I cannot see Dutch parliamentary speaker Martin Bosma pulling such stunts any time soon.

Relations changed not only domestically, with the FPÖ as the largest party, but abroad as well. There are now numerous right-wing governments, in various versions (the Netherlands, Italy, Sweden), while in France and Germany the front women Marine Le Pen and Alice Weidel are hammering on the gates of power.

It has become far more difficult for the European Commission and the European Parliament, in which the European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR) form the third group, to nail Austria to the cross as they did in 2000 and 2017. Among European heads of government, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni is the Madonna of conservative Europe. Whoever offends her gets it back in a double portion. Just ask French President Emmanuel Macron.

The most pressing theme in the negotiations in Vienna is indeed European: the budget rules, in particular the 3 percent norm for the budget deficit. Before the elections the government said the deficit was 2.8 percent, but shortly afterwards it turned out to be 4 percent! That meant 18 billion in extra cuts. The liberal NEOS wanted hard measures; the Socialists dug in their heels and the ÖVP looked toward the FPÖ. So Kickl, as formateur, gets the 18 billion euro invoice pushed under his nose. FPÖ and ÖVP have already agreed to cut 6.3 billion euros in order to avert a so-called ‘excessive deficit procedure’ by the European Commission, and with it a downgrade of Austrian creditworthiness on the financial markets.

The negotiations with the FPÖ are reminiscent of those with the PVV. The first thing the FPÖ heard from ÖVP negotiator Christian Stocker: ‘Ein Öxit kommt nicht in Frage’. Öxit is the Austrian variant of Brexit and Nexit. Kickl may voice criticism, but there is a hard limit.

The FPÖ criticises sanctions against Russia and, like the PVV, will have to change course. Vienna of course hopes the blessing will come from elsewhere: a peace settlement via Donald Trump. And a ‘Bundeskanzler Kickl’ will have to abide by the rule of law. In short: constitutionality, à la Pieter Omtzigt. Remarkable: immigration is barely a point of contention, except that the ÖVP uses a different vocabulary. Most important: will the ‘Kickl mayonnaise’ set, as far as mutual trust is concerned?

That is relevant, because in December an old acquaintance suddenly appeared on the German ARD talk show of Sandra Maischberger: Sebastian Kurz. He said he was happy in business, but ruled nothing out. Admittedly he has meanwhile received a suspended sentence of eight months in prison for making false statements. A trial over the buying of newspaper advertisements in exchange for positive opinion polls, along the lines of the Strache method, is still running.

Kurz and Kickl have buried the hatchet, they say, but if formateur Kickl fails and thereby provokes ‘Neuwahlen’, the ÖVP still has one vote-getting cannon standing ready: Sebastian Kurz!

Derk Jan Eppink is a Distinguished Fellow (Honorary) at the Gold Institute for International Strategy, a Washington D.C.-based foreign policy and defense think tank.

Under Siege: How the War on Farmers Threatens Western Values and Global Food Security

Farmers protest in a city street with tractors and people gathered

(This article was written by Rob Roos and appeared in The European Conservative. Under Siege: How the War on Farmers Threatens Western Values and Global Food Security)

Farmers are the backbone of society, ensuring that our tables are filled with food three times a day, every day of the week. Yet, in the modern world, their indispensable role is often taken for granted. We rarely pause to consider that the contents of our refrigerators connect us directly to those who labor tirelessly to sustain us. What happens if the farmers disappear? The answer is simple and stark: our refrigerators remain empty. Food security, once a cornerstone of national policy and identity, is now being eroded by globalist ideologies and bureaucratic overreach, threatening not just agriculture but the very fabric of Western civilization.

The historical significance of food security cannot be overstated. After the devastation of World War II, European nations understood the fragility of their food supplies. Hunger, shortages, and economic instability plagued the continent, prompting the creation of the European Economic Community (EEC). A key component of this new cooperative effort was the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), established in 1962. Its purpose was clear: to ensure stable, sufficient food production, reduce dependence on imports, and protect citizens from the specter of future shortages. It succeeded in turning Europe into a self-sufficient agricultural powerhouse while upholding high standards of food safety and quality.

Fast forward to today, and the situation could not be more different. The European Union (EU), driven by unelected bureaucrats in the European Commission, has turned its back on its founding principles. Under the guise of environmental sustainability and climate policy, the EU has declared war on its farmers, implementing measures that force them off the land. These policies, varying by country but united in their destructive outcomes, are choking the life out of European agriculture. In the Netherlands, nitrogen emissions are the scapegoat; in Germany, farmers are being taxed into oblivion. The result is the same: despair, financial ruin, and a troubling rise in farmer suicides.

The assault on farmers is not confined to Europe. Across the globe, agriculture is under siege. In the United States and Australia, water regulations are driving farmers to the brink. In Canada, fertilizer restrictions are crippling productivity. New Zealand targets methane emissions, while South American farmers face an onslaught of environmental and economic pressures. From a broader perspective, these trends suggest a coordinated effort to dismantle the traditional foundations of food production in Western societies.

Why is this happening, and who stands to benefit? These questions point to a deeply troubling agenda. History provides a grim warning. Stalin’s collectivization policies in the 1930s decimated the Ukrainian peasantry, leading to the Holodomor—a man-made famine that claimed millions of lives. Similarly, Mao’s Great Leap Forward in the 1960s wreaked havoc on Chinese agriculture, causing widespread starvation. In both cases, the destruction of farmers paved the way for the consolidation of Communist power. The parallels with today’s assault on agriculture are chilling.

At the heart of this assault lies a globalist agenda spearheaded by the United Nations (UN). Cloaked in the rhetoric of sustainability and equality, the UN’s policies often serve the interests of unelected elites rather than the citizens they claim to represent. Through initiatives like Agenda 2030 and the woke climate agenda, the UN advances a vision of top-down control that sidelines national sovereignty and democratic accountability. The role of powerful NGOs, funded by wealthy philanthropists with vested financial interests, further illustrates how unelected actors dictate policy. These oligarchs, shielded by their philanthropic facades, wield immense influence over supranational organizations, bypassing the will of the people.

The climate narrative is a prime example of this manipulation. Fear of climate catastrophe is being weaponized to impose draconian restrictions on farmers while conveniently ignoring the hypocrisy of global trade policies. If climate concerns were genuine, why does the EU continue to sign trade agreements that import food from regions with lax environmental standards? Beans from Kenya, for instance, are shipped across the globe despite being grown under far less stringent regulations than those faced by European farmers. This exposes the true agenda: control, not conservation.

Moreover, the climate-driven assault on agriculture is part of a broader effort to dismantle Western values. The UN’s Immigration Replacement agenda floods Western nations with non-Western immigrants, diluting and disrupting our cultural heritage which is organically and carefully crafted over the centuries on Judeo-Christian values and Greek philosophy. Simultaneously, traditional farming communities are being undermined, eroding a way of life that has long been a pillar of national identity and economic stability. The aim appears to be the creation of a homogenized, compliant global citizenry, stripped of cultural and economic independence.

For conservatives, the stakes could not be higher. Agriculture is more than an economic sector; it is a cornerstone of sovereignty, community, and tradition. The farmer is not just a food producer but a steward of the land, a guardian of heritage, and a bulwark against the encroachments of globalism. When farmers are forced off their land, society loses more than food security—it loses a vital connection to its roots and values.

The path forward requires a reassertion of national sovereignty and a rejection of globalist overreach. Governments must prioritize local food production, support farmers through fair and reasonable policies, and resist the siren song of supranational organizations. Trade policies must reflect environmental realities, encouraging local and sustainable farming practices rather than outsourcing food production to distant, poorly regulated regions.

Ultimately, the attack on farmers is an attack on the freedoms and values that define Western society. An empty refrigerator is not just an inconvenience; it is a symbol of dependence, vulnerability, and submission. To protect our farmers is to protect our freedom, our heritage, and our future. Let us not repeat the mistakes of history by allowing ideological zealotry and bureaucratic hubris to destroy the foundations of our civilization. Because—no farmers, no food, no future.

Rob Roos is a Distinguished Fellow (Honorary) at the Gold Institute for International Strategy, a Washington D.C.-based foreign policy and defense think tank.

Only the Agreeable Vote Counts

European Union flag flying beneath a stone arch in Brussels

(This article was written by Hermann Tertsch and appeared in El Debate. Solo vale el voto amable)

Former commissioner Thierry Breton is threatening that the European Union will annul any election held in a European country whose results it considers the fruit of outside interference. “We did it in Romania and we will obviously have to do it if it is necessary in Germany”, he proclaimed on television with the assurance of a man who has already talked it over with the people who matter and who can make it happen.

What Breton is saying is that the European Union, presumably the European Commission in agreement with the losers of the respective elections, just as has happened in Romania, will annul, using the argument, justification or pretext of foreign interference, any election whose results do not ideologically satisfy Brussels.

The former French commissioner, known for his outbursts against freedom of expression, expressed this absolute contempt for the sovereignty and democratic will of the EU’s member countries while commenting on the debate held on the X network between the owner of that network, Elon Musk, and the candidate for the chancellorship of the Alternative for Germany party (AfD). The traditional parties, all of them now on the left of the political spectrum, brand the AfD as far right. When in reality it occupies the entire conservative space left orphaned by the CDU when Angela Merkel took the party of Adenauer and Helmut Kohl to the centre-left, pushing socialists and greens toward ever greater radicalism in their interventionist and social engineering theses, which have brought Germany to its worst economic and social crisis since the Second World War.

Europe’s power elites, among whom Breton plays a very prominent role, are in a panic after the catastrophe of the parties of the social democratic consensus in Austria. There the FPÖ won the election. In an operation applauded from Brussels and contrary to custom, to the rule and to logic, the head of state, Alexander van der Bellen, denied the FPÖ the right to try to form a government and gave it to the second most voted party, the Austrian People’s Party (ÖVP). The ÖVP tried to build a three-party coalition against the FPÖ with the socialists and the left-wing liberals, but after months of negotiations they failed. Among other reasons because the polls showed that the public was responding with ever greater support for the FPÖ. In three months the FPÖ has gone from 28 per cent in the election to 39 per cent in the latest polls. The other parties and the discredited Van der Bellen had to entrust Herbert Kickl’s FPÖ with the task of forming a government.

What in Austria is a nightmare for the elites would in Germany be hell for them. That is why they appear to be announcing already that Europe’s elites are claiming for themselves the right to decide which electoral results suit the future of their peculiar democracy and which do not. And the latter are annulled, with the pretext of outside intervention.

That is exactly what has happened in Romania, where weeks after this scandal, more befitting Nicolás Maduro than Europe, there is not a single piece of evidence that there was Russian interference in the annulled elections. What is more, a week later the legislative elections were held with a result that struck them as acceptable and nobody complained. Why would Russia interfere in the presidential election and not in the legislative one, which forms the government and is far more significant politically?

On the contrary, there is a great deal of information indicating that it was the governing party of Marcel Ciolacu itself, the PSD, the so-called social democratic party that takes in the survivors of the communist apparatus, that was cheering on and promoting the candidate Calin Georgescu on social media, believing that he would be the easiest candidate to beat in the second round. But they underestimated the collapse in the popularity of the prime minister, who believed his passage to the second round was assured and was beaten by the centre-right candidate Elena Lasconi, so that the entire left and the old mafia apparatus were left without a candidate in the second round. That being so, they turned to their old president of the Constitutional Court who, as in Spain, is a lackey of the prime minister, and instructed him to correct his position. And if on the Tuesday after the election he said that everything had been correct, by Friday he had detected enough Russian interference to annul the election. Breton makes it clear that this coup d’état and theft of an election that has taken place in Romania was carried out under the baton of Brussels.

This used to be called “the Brezhnev Doctrine”, as older readers will recall. This direct threat to the popular will of the European nations reveals the true drift of the power of the bureaucracy controlled by those elites. It had already shown itself in other forms of abuse, such as Von der Leyen’s threats ahead of elections, for example in Italy, warning the electorate not to get its vote wrong because it would suffer the consequences. This has happened on a massive scale in other countries, and the interference of Brussels and Berlin in Poland, for example, has been scandalous and brutal. The ideological discrimination coming from the European Commission is already a scandal and a genuine act of brutality. Under Von der Leyen it already behaves openly like an authoritarian government toward its provinces, punishing and rewarding according to ideological submission, when in reality its legal function is that of a mere administrator of the decisions of the European Council formed by the sovereign nations.

It is not known in what capacity Breton speaks this way when he is no longer commissioner of anything. He is officially devoted to his lucrative businesses and connections with the big technology and telecommunications industry, which incredibly were no obstacle to his serving as commissioner for the Internal Market, despite such obvious and obscene conflicts of interest.

Take note that Breton was speaking in the royal plural, or perhaps as the representative of that unelected elite which controls the whole European bureaucracy, feeds the media and regards itself as a sanhedrin that would act as the real government of the European Union above the European Commission. We shall see what happens. For now all we know is that the AfD in Germany keeps rising and the CDU, the People’s Party, keeps falling. A year ago more than 20 points separated them. Today barely eight points separate them. If this continues, with Alternative for Germany showing itself moderate, reasonable and politically intelligent while the CDU remains stubbornly intent on displaying as its highest ambition a return to governing with the socialists or the greens in order to go on doing the same thing that has led to the disaster of insecurity, poverty, precariousness and exhaustion, they may urgently have to look for some outside interference. But if they annul an election in Germany as Breton threatens, they are annulling the European Union. And in one blow.

Hermann Tertsch is a Distinguished Fellow (Honorary) at the Gold Institute for International Strategy, a Washington D.C.-based foreign policy and defense think tank.

Elon Musk Shakes Up the German Establishment

Front view of the historic Reichstag building in Berlin, Germany

(This article was written by Derk Jan Eppink and appeared in Wynia’s Week. Elon Musk schudt het Duitse dekbed op)

Germany is bracing for the ‘conversation’ on X between Trump confidant Elon Musk and the AfD parliamentary leader in the Bundestag, Alice Weidel. With his 211 million followers, Musk can cast a very wide net. Meanwhile the German political elite sits trembling. Musk praises Weidel because he sees the Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) as a saving angel that Germany’s large parties have sealed off behind a cordon sanitaire. It is the first time a prominent American has come to shake up the German bed, and with such enormous media reach, right before the elections.

The British have already had their portion. Through his X account Musk took aim at the British establishment by calling on King Charles III to dissolve parliament. He also demanded the resignation of Prime Minister Keir Starmer. The occasion was reporting on sexual violence by mainly Pakistani groups against underage British girls. The ‘grooming’ practice among Pakistanis was already known, but the authorities remained lax. Labour above all, which governs cities in the English Midlands such as Birmingham, covered up the appalling practice of gang rapes with a cloak of charity. According to Musk, Starmer’s government is a ‘group of gangsters’.

The leader of the Reform UK party, Nigel Farage, tried to soften Musk’s statements, but got nowhere. On X, Musk, who had earlier wanted to donate 100 million dollars to Reform UK, announced that Farage had to go. Tommy Robinson, a British anti-Islam activist sitting in an isolation cell for opinion offences, was to be brought into the party leadership. Farage rejected that idea outright, because it would mean the end of Reform UK, on account of two captains on one ship.

Musk’s missionary actions in Great Britain stem from the fact that he is a committed ‘natalist’, an advocate of high birth rates. Musk argues for large families and is himself the father of 12 children, by 3 women. Such numbers would be ‘hors catégorie’ even for the Vatican. He hammers on the point that Western Europe is going under because of low birth rates. Through high immigration figures, Western Europe is de facto abolishing itself. As a family man he openly denounces Pakistani sexual violence against many thousands of girls, with hard swipes at the lax British establishment. Starmer and his party colleagues look the other way. Musk’s tweets were fed by understandable anger and revulsion alive among British citizens.

Is Musk’s punitive expedition a personal whim, or is there also a political dimension? In 2016, Donald Trump as incoming president was already making critical statements about the Germany of Angela Merkel. He denounced her ‘welcome culture’, as well as the closing of German nuclear plants and the dependence on Russian gas. On 28 September 2018 Trump repeated the latter point during the UN General Assembly in New York, but he was laughed at by the German delegation, including the German foreign minister Heiko Maas. The facts proved Trump right. His relationship with the British Conservative government was good, above all with Prime Minister Boris Johnson. That changed with the arrival of Starmer.

Both Starmer and German Chancellor Olaf Scholz accuse Musk of ‘interference’. Scholz, however, regularly hands out ‘voting advice’ abroad, as in France. Labour sent 100 paid activists to the United States to support Kamala in her election campaign. The lead candidate of the German Christian Democrats, Friedrich Merz, called an opinion article by Musk in Welt am Sonntag ‘intrusive and presumptuous’. If, however, Merz does not run a right-wing campaign and lets himself be swayed by the left, he will make the AfD bigger all by himself. The legendary Bavarian politician Franz Josef Strauss (1915-1988) invariably said: ‘to the right of me there is no room’. That room has now appeared. The AfD dived into it.

It is striking that Trump no longer carries out disruptive actions himself, but leaves them to Musk with his network of 211 million followers. Musk is the ‘bad guy’ (a role that suits him) and Trump watches from the sidelines. A strategic division of labour.

Musk nurses more irritation about Germany: his investments in the ‘Tesla Gigafactory’ in Grünheide in the German state of Brandenburg. An investment of 4 billion euros with 12,500 employees. It is the largest electric car factory in Europe. But Musk is getting stuck in German red tape and resistance from environmental activists. They camp in tents on new construction sites because trees are being felled. An attack was carried out on the power supply so that production lay idle for days. Employees no longer dare walk outside the company grounds in Tesla clothing.

Musk sees how Germany is bogging down in indecisiveness and in the terror of environmental activists who always praised electric cars in the fight against climate change. Musk himself is not a climate sceptic: he supports the same goal. He started Tesla back in 2003, when climate policy was still in its infancy. Which testifies to a farsighted entrepreneurial eye.

Nor does Musk come from conservative circles. Born in South Africa in 1971, he knew apartheid. His father Errol fought apartheid on the Pretoria city council, as a member of the ‘Progressive Party’ (PP). At eighteen Musk left with his mother for Canada and afterwards studied economics and physics at the University of Pennsylvania in America. There he stayed.

Musk became known for his entrepreneurial talents with SpaceX (spaceflight), Starlink (satellites), Tesla and related enterprises. He is driven. His management style is characterised by terms such as: micromanager, autocrat, tirades. He comes across as an overactive teenager, thinks faster than he can speak, and is autistic (Asperger’s), like Greta Thunberg, whom he follows on X. Once Musk has a goal in view, he keeps drilling. Trump is narcissistic and loves the mirror. From a psychological point of view, an intriguing pair.

Until recently Musk voted for Democrats; in 2016 for Hillary Clinton, in 2020 for Joe Biden. One personal core theme drove him into politics: freedom of expression. He turned against political correctness, bans on speech and thought, and above all against ‘woke’, which became a religion among Democrats. Musk went into resistance in favour of ‘freedom of speech’. In April 2022 he bought Twitter for 43 billion dollars and rechristened the company X. In fact X is one of the largest media companies in the world, if not the largest.

With X, Musk fills a gap in America created by the decline of what he calls the ‘legacy media’, the ‘old media’. ‘Progressive media’ above all supported Democrats by every means; even Joe Biden’s malfunctioning was ingeniously covered up. Until his fatal debate with Trump. The New York Times and the Washington Post were badly exposed. CNN and MSNBC saw their ratings collapse by 50%. Rupert Murdoch’s media empire, News Corp, with Fox News, the Wall Street Journal and the New York Post, remains on its feet. Progressive media lost the trust of the public. With X, Musk is taking over the debate, and exporting it worldwide.

So the ‘Musk method’ has arrived in Western Europe. Germany is a stumbling block for both Trump and Musk. For Trump it is personal; for Musk ideological. They want more resolve and less know-it-all posturing. For Starmer there is no respect. Macron they leave untouched, because he devalues himself. Meloni is their lady; Orban their darling. Of the Netherlands there is no picture, though Wilders appears on the radar.

From 20 January onwards Musk will throw himself into the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) to take the knife to the American federal bureaucracy. In official Washington D.C. the chips will fly, because the arch-enemy is nothing less than the ‘Deep State’. ‘High Noon’ is on the way!

Derk Jan Eppink is a Distinguished Fellow (Honorary) at the Gold Institute for International Strategy, a Washington D.C.-based foreign policy and defense think tank.

The Failures of the Intelligence Agencies and the Secret Service Preparing for 2025 Post-election Protests and Beyond

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

In the wake of the ever-increasing Presidential campaign rhetoric from both the Democrats and the Republicans since the 2020 election, disturbing narratives have focused, fairly or unfairly, on the outcome and results of the 2024 Presidential election. The Republicans continue to be riled for numerous reasons—citing unfair MAGA characterizations, the vilification of anyone who attended the January 6, 2021 protests, the unfettered immigration of millions of unvetted multi-national migrants, inflation, lawlessness, escalating war(s) in the Middle East and numerous, disturbing examples of a two-tiered justice system targeting former President Trump and many of his former staff. The Democrats have been ignoring these claims or minimizing their effects stating these issues are being exaggerated for political purposes. Instead, the White House and their minions defaulted to women’s abortion rights, healthcare benefits, DEI ideology, defunding the police, supporting Palestinian sympathizers’ rights and “saving democracy.” The Democrats have continually defaulted to blaming Trump for “inciting” the violent protests at the Capitol on January 6, 2021 and an exponential array of problems plaguing America. These divergent positions have sparked outrage since then on both sides. As a result, the lead up to the 2024 election was contentious and the Trump win has law enforcement circles concerned that post-election events have the potential to be contentious and disruptive.[1] [2]

This article, written before the election, is being updated as of January 6, 2025 in light of the convincing Trump Presidential win and his Cabinet and officials’ selections. Ranking Democrats, donors, governors and mayors in many blue states have begun to launch concerted offensives to thwart the Trump agenda as much as possible as outlined in The New York Times:

The panels range from sweeping subjects — “Making Meaning and Meeting the Moment: Resistance and Reorienting” and “It’s Time to Resist: The Fight Against Project 2025” — to more focused discussions about abortion rights, immigration, racial justice, taxes, countering disinformation and other issues, according to a draft agenda.[3]

Several of Trump’s cabinet nominees and other White House team picks have already been targeted with bomb threats and “swatting.”[4] These efforts to disrupt the transition to the Trump administration has the potential to inflame supporters from both sides.

Prior to the election politically charged bi-partisan rhetoric fostered a remarkable awakening in the populus of the country. Given this and the convincing Trump win, the stage was/is seemingly set for potential unrest prior to the Inauguration of President-elect Trump on January 20, 2025. There were and are numerous overlapping concerns that contribute to this. Key among them are the intelligence agencies’ warnings that foreign enemy states, i.e. Russia, China and Iran are planning to wreak post-election havoc. The Trump campaign and Harris campaign had reported hacks and disruptions into its servers. Iran openly revealed assassination plots targeting Trump. As of November 8, 2024, the FBI had confirmed Iran was planning a Trump assassination with two suspects arrested in the U.S. and one other identified in Iran.[5] Adding to this disturbing threat information, intelligence and public media reporting indicates current enemy states: China, Russia and North Korea are partnering with the professed unifying goal of undermining the U.S. election process. Further, intelligence agencies have shared concerns these enemy states pose collective threats to the U.S. and in “multiple parts in the world simultaneously.”[6] Alarmingly, FBI Director Wray has acknowledged a dangerous influx of more than 100 known terrorists and thousands of dangerous criminals across the southern and northern borders, but admits their whereabouts are unknown.

Notably numerous congressional hearings, Inspectors General reports and media reports confirm the Department of Justice (DOJ), the intelligence agencies—especially the FBI, have failed to fulfill their respective missions. This includes misrepresenting the COVID origins, implementing a two-tired justice system targeting Trump and associated conservatives, targeting Right to Life advocates, proposing classifying parents as “domestic terrorists”…all while turning a blind eye to the criminal schemes of President Biden and the Clintons.[7]

In the context of what has transpired before the election and now post-election 2024; three key elements are being addressed accordingly:

1. The benefits of robust integrated security preparation as a deterrent to post election protests prior to the Inauguration;

2. Improving the Secret Service; its performance and future as the nation’s elite protective federal agency;

3. Reforming the deep state leading up to prevent sabotaging the current and future presidents and implementing reforms identified by the several congressional committee investigative and Inspectors General reports.

Factors Contributing to Inauguration Day Protest Concerns and Future Post Election Events

In an effort to provide context to factors that may fuel potential protests and unrest following the election and during the Inauguration of Donald Trump as the 47th President of the United States and beyond, the following, verified background is being set forth. It is important to understand the factors contributing to the ongoing vitriol, particularly from the Democrats pre and post the 2024 election. This includes disparaging political comments made by many former and current Democrat Cabinet level officials, many of their respective staff members, military officials, state and local officials, numerous media outlets and corporate leaders. This unprecedented level of divisive rhetoric, demonization, vilification (based on fabricated claims), has deteriorated to personal assaults and has infected large swaths of the populus. With the abandonment, in some cases, of any serious effort to clarify and fact check claims promulgated from both sides, the partisan division grew to dangerous levels in the country. Even more alarming, these circumstances have signaled opportunities for enemy state regimes to exploit the United States to gain economic advantage and power, especially during the presidential transition. There are innumerable examples of this. Salient among them are the withdrawal of the U.S. presence from Afghanistan, funding Iran with billions of dollars and the disinformation infecting the country’s social media outlets to include information concerning China, Russia and Iran. The resulting divisive political rancor has intensified since 2016 and there is no indication of any let up. All of this points to potentially dangerous unrest in the months to come.

Following the 2016 Donald Trump presidential victory, his 2020 presidential bid and now his second election as the 47th President of the United States, empirical and documented evidence show former President Trump, members of his family, his newly named staff members and other surrogates have been subjected to innumerable political assaults and threats. Historically these included frivolous claims of Russian collusion, accusations of improper collaboration with Ukraine, targeted entrapment investigations against his staff, mainstream media outlets promulgating false and damaging narratives and recruiting 51 intelligence officials to engage in election interference. This includes the fabrication of prosecutions and convictions based on tenuous legal grounds violating due process by the Justice Department—all in an effort to delegitimize the Trump presidency and his 2024 presidential bid.[8] Few media outlets have reported these politically damaging efforts. Many can be traced directly to the leaders and staffs of the Democrat party. They blatantly misrepresented Trump’s 2024 Campaign promises and voiced plans to derail Trump’s transition with a variety of tactics. Enemy states are expected to exploit this misinformation in manipulative ways. Many media outlets have reported ranking democrat efforts to “Trump proof” his administration with last-minute executive orders.[9]

The New Yorker reported Russia and Iran were using Artificial Intelligence (AI) to promulgate “deep fakes” ahead of the election to spread “conspiratorial narratives” and amplifying “divisive U.S. issues to denigrate the election process.[10] Now we can expect this to reimplemented, post-election, to disrupt the transition.

Prior to the decisive Trump re-election ranking Democrats, namely Jamie Raskin, Ranking Member of the Committee on Oversight and Accountability and several senior Democrats in Congress would not commit to certifying the results of the 2024 Presidential election if former President Donald Trump won.[11] [12] [13]

These articles highlight the importance of preparing de-escalation measures to avoid a repeat of the disruption and protests of the January 6, 2021 experience

As of this writing it appears there are plans in the works by leading Democrats to “Trump proof” earlier liberal initiatives and dilute the 2nd Trump administration’s agenda.[14] [15]

The Need for Effective, Integrated Security Planning for the Inauguration and Future Events

Capitalizing on the January 6, 2021 protests/riots, Russia and Iran were considering a repeat in the event of a Trump lost.[16] The National Intelligence Council (NIC) in a memorandum dated October 8, 2024, reports several disruptive scenarios were and are being planned by Russia and Iran with the goal to denigrate the U.S. political process and transfer of power.[17]

There is a documented history of intelligence failures highlighting this concern. If the tepid intelligence provided by the FBI and the DHS Office of Intelligence Analysis (I&A) to Capitol Police Chief Sund and the U.S. Park Police (USPP) prior to January 6, 2021 of planned riots is any indication of what to expect during the Inauguration and beyond, there are legitimate concerns. (The vote certification on January 6, 2025 was conducted without incident). The Capitol Police (USCP), DC Metropolitan Police (DCMP), the USPP, the U.S. Secret Service and the public deserve accurate and complete information from these agencies with respect to anticipated crowd size, crowd composition and planned protests for major events. Scalable security planning requires this. This was not the case prior to January 6, 2021. In fact the January 6, 2021 vote certification was not declared a National Special Security Event (NSSE) by DHS despite the fact the existing intelligence fit the DHS vulnerability rating criteria to declare it. This designation is required when a planned major event is a potential target of terrorism or other criminal activity.[18] Had the Secret Service Protective Intelligence Division (PID) been included in the full disclosure of the existing intelligence regarding anticipated crowd sizes, planned protests and violence for January 6, 2021 they would have made the case to declare the vote certification an NSSE.

Several post January 6, 2021 after-action reviews have documented a myriad of intelligence and planning failures by the FBI, DHS-I&A and the Secret Service leading up to and after the 2021 protests.[19] [20] Worse, indications of disruptive protests by several groups known to the FBI and

I&A with active investigations were not shared with the USCP and other planners. Evidence of alarming social media posts and protest meetings documented in investigations by many FBI field offices were diluted and and/or simply not shared. Reports, studies and testimony of these failures have been drowned out by those that chose to use January 6th as a political tool to dominate the political discussion with a version that appeared to be used to suit a partisan agenda. Two post January 6th reports dated June 27, 2023 and July 10, 2023 document the investigations by U.S. Senator Gary Peters, Chairman of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee cite significant intelligence failures by the FBI and I&A leading up to the January 6, 2021 protest.[21]

Former USCP Chief Sund stated that January 6 was a ‘Cover-Up’ by intelligence officials in power at the time and “they were aware of the attack in advance and covered it up by failing to disseminate the information to those who needed it.”[22] In an interview with Tucker Carlson that never aired, Sund repeated this claim and subsequent congressional investigations corroborated this. In this interview and in his book: Courage Under Fire, Sund explains, with definitive chronological clarity, supported by documents, that he was denied access to the DC National Guard troops for 71 minutes after asking for them at 1 PM on January 6. Sund further stated it took more than three hours after that during an excruciating “approval process” for the District of Columbia National Guard (DCNG) troops to be mobilized. Major General William Walker, commander of the DCNG stated during a Joint hearing he was not given the authorization to deploy them. General Walker stated: “the delay was caused at least in part over concerns of the optics of sending uniformed troops to the scene.” General Walker further testified he received an “unusual” restrictive order to delay a quick troop deployment without the “explicit” approval of of then-Secretary of the Army Ryan McCarthy.[23] On January 11, 2021, Sund told the Washington Post he disagreed with Nancy Pelosi’s claim that “Additional security could have been provided but no one from the Capitol requested it.” Sund maintains his six separate requests were denied. He also warned federal officials “if they don’t’ get their act together, it will happen again.”[24]

Reports of several requests for intelligence information, prior to January 6, 2021, by Chief Sund are well documented and are confirmed in the following congressional investigative reports. Numerous committee reports outline failures of the FBI and I&A to share intelligence with law enforcement preparing for the January 6, 2021 vote certification. These have been sparsely reported/referenced in media reporting of the January 6th Hearings and Investigations; among them:

· Anna Skinner, Ex-Capitol Police Chief Sounds Alarm That Jan. 6 Was ‘Cover-Up’, NEWSWEEK, (August 6, 2023);

· Alana Wise, DOD Took Hours To Approve National Guard Request During Capitol Riot, Commander Says, NPR, (March 3, 2021);

· Todd Spangler, Peters’ report details failures ahead of Jan. 6 attack, calls for changes, DETROIT FREE PRESS, (June 8, 2021);

· HSGAC Majority Staff Report, Chairman Gary Peters, Planned in Plain Sight: A Review of the Intelligence Failures in Advance of January 6th, 2021, (June 2023);

· Committee on House Administration, Chairman Brian Steil, DoD Inspector General Concealed January 6 Evidence,(November 21, 2024); [25]

· DOJ OIG, REP-250-011, “A Review of the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s Handling of Its Confidential Human Sources and Intelligence Collection Efforts in the Lead Up to the January 6, 2021 Electoral Certification” (December 2024).

The key findings are as follows: [26] [27]

  • FBI and I&A received numerous early warnings, tips, and other intelligence about plans for violence on January 6th;
  • FBI produced only two limited raw intelligence documents related to January 6th, both issued the night before the attack, and I&A did not issue any intelligence products specific to January 6th;
  • Despite claims by some agency officials and analysts, FBI and I&A have authority to monitor open-source intelligence, including social media – and agency guidelines require them to report certain online threats; and
  • FBI and I&A failed to follow agency guidelines on the use of open-source intelligence.

A detailed review of all the findings were documented in the Planned In Plain Sight – A Review of the Intelligence Failures in Advance of January 6, 2021.[28] Specifically, this review by the United States Senate Committee On Homeland Security & Governmental Affairs stated:

“The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Office of Intelligence and Analysis (I&A) – obtained multiple tips from numerous sources in the days and weeks leading up to the attack that should have raised alarms. Rather, those agencies failed to fully and accurately assess the severity of the threat identified by that intelligence and formally disseminate guidance to their law enforcement partners with sufficient urgency and alarm to enable those partners to prepare for the violence that ultimately occurred on January 6th. At a fundamental level, the agencies failed to fulfill their mission and connect the public and nonpublic information they received. Internal emails and

documents obtained by the Committee demonstrate the breadth and gravity of the threats these agencies received related to January 6th. For example, FBI and the Department of Justice (DOJ) received tips and information from multiple sources, including:”

· In December 2020, FBI received a tip that the Proud Boys planned to be in DC and “[t]heir plan is to literally kill people. Please, please take this tip seriously and investigate further.”

· On Jan. 3, 2021, FBI also became aware of multiple posts calling for armed violence, such as a Parler user who stated, “[b]ring food and guns. If they don’t listen to our words, they can feel our lead. Come armed”; plans to “set up ‘armed encampment’ on the[National] Mall”; and a tip about “a TikTok video with someone holding a gun saying, ‘storm the Capitol on January 6th.’”

· On January 4th, DOJ leadership noted multiple concerning posts, including “[c]alls to occupy federal buildings,”discussions of “invading the capitol building,” and individuals “arm[ing] themselves and to engage in political violence at the event.”

In addition, on March 22, 2022, the DHS Office of Inspector General (DHSIG) also noted in its report the I&A had identified viable threats prior to January 6, 2021 but did not issue any intelligence products before the U.S. Capitol breach.

On December 29, 2020, the I&A’s Counterterrorism Mission Center (CTMC) sent a Request for Information (RFI) to the Open-Source Collection Operation for threat information concerning the January 6 events to include:

· Online calls by event organizers to bring weapons to lawful protesters to counter protests;

· An increase in lawful protesters / counter protesters in DC, carrying, brandishing or using lethal weapons, such as firearms or edged weapons;

· Specific, directed threats of violence towards…prominent ideological adversaries or figures associated with an ideological movement; and

· Violent extremists posing a threat to individuals to include law enforcement and government officials holding opposing views prior to scheduled events.

Further, collectors of the sources messaged each other with related concerns but did not issue intelligence reports. In sum, no warnings were issued claiming these threats and other direct threats “did not fit the guidelines.” They were not widely disseminated, until after January 6, 2021.[29]

These and other specific threats were not shared with the USCP despite Chief Sund’s intelligence requests and two (2) intelligence assessment meetings with the FBI and the I&A prior to the January 6, 2021 vote certification and subsequent riots.

These facts were further corroborated by Joseph V. Cuffari, Inspector General in his report dated March 4, 2022: I&A Identified Threats prior to January 6, 2021, but Did Not Issue Any Intelligence Products before the U.S. Capitol Breach. The direct responsibility and culpability of the intelligence agencies, namely the FBI and the I&A, has been conflated and in many cases conspicuously absent from media reporting and investigations to include the January 6th Committee.

The DHSIG in their report evaluating the Secret Service’s preparation and response to the events of January 6, 2021 determined the Secret Service PID prepared two (2) reports indicating the likelihood of violence based on various reports, sources and tips but did not take commensurate protective actions.

The facts cited above added to the concerns about the security planning prior to the 2025 vote certification and the upcoming Inauguration. Many leaders and rank and file members of the USCP, the DCMP, the DCNG, the Republican House and Senate and media outlets expressed this. There are valid reasons for this. It is noted the original DoD Office of Inspector General (DoD IG) Report No. 2022-039, dated November 16, 2021 entitled: “Review of the DoD’s Role, Responsibilities, and Actions to Prepare for and Respond to the Protest and its Aftermath at the U.S. Capitol Campus on January 6, 2021,” was submitted as the final review of the DoD’s actions on January 6, 2021. Due to the numerous investigations, reports and testimony of officials with direct knowledge and roles prior to and during January 6 vote certification, conflicting facts were uncovered.

For these reasons, Barry Loudermilk, Chairman of the Subcommittee on Oversight sent a letter to Inspector General Robert P. Storch, dated November 21, 2024 requesting “a full correction” to the DoD IG’s inaccurate findings and statements regarding the intelligence and security failures on January 6.[30] Numerous, key witnesses, eight (8), were intentionally not interviewed. Subsequent investigations determined their accounts of the DoD’s command responses to urgent requests directly contradicted the DoD IG’s report. Chairman’s Loudermilk’s conclusion: “The inability of the DoD IG to adequately review these and other DoD actions on January 6 has informed the Subcommittee’s finding that DoD IG is complicit in intentionally concealing DoD actions to delay the DCNG’s response to the Capitol on January 6.”

Additionally, recent some media outlets are reporting, due to these and other exacerbating circumstances, law enforcement may not be adequately prepared for the Inauguration on January 20, 2025. Tenuous relationships and the history of selective information sharing between the FBI and the USCP along with the Secret Service has fostered a level of skepticism regarding intelligence gaps. This distrust has further eroded the trust in the intelligence agencies, particularly with the FBI with the release of Senator Grassley’s letter dated December 9, 2024 to FBI Director Wray detailing the extent of FBI’s abuses.[31] In addition, the Secret Service is facing scrutiny due a “loss” relevant emails from January 6, 2021 and continuing into 2024 to include sparse information releases following the two Trump assassination attempts and related missteps. In the wake of the Chairman Kelly’s Final Report by the U.S. House of Representatives Task Force on the Attempted Assassination of Donald Trump, the ability of the Secret Service to protect Trump and other protectees is being called into question.[32] This is in part being attributed to a lack of reliable intelligence, a lack of competence, lack of requisite funding, lack of training and as whistleblowers contend—partisan pressure from the current administration and DHS to dilute security resources for the Trump detail. Due to these and other facts, the ability of the USCP and the Secret Service to maintain order and security in its preparation for the Inauguration on January 20, 2025 and beyond is a concern and is being questioned.

Moving forward in 2025 the Secret Service and other law enforcement agencies are collectively facing a disturbing quandary of mistrust across the board…discriminating fact from disinformation is becoming increasingly challenging as of this writing. The need for integrated, robust and complete operational planning with the USCP, the Secret Service, USPP, DCMP along with the DCNG is a serious concern. Further, the critical and immediate need for the FBI and I&A to be transparent, diligent and forthcoming with ALL relevant intelligence (real time) impacting the Inauguration and future events is mandatory.

These concerns in 2025 are legitimate based on documented facts of poor integration among law enforcement agencies, diluted threat information sharing and attempts to coverup the intentional, delayed responses of DoD resources to the Capitol riots on January 6, 2021. Specifically, the in-depth chronology of the preparations, miscommunications and intentional delays to release DCNG troops, DCMP police officers and crowd suppression resources are well documented in Chief Sund’s book, Courage Under Fire, Under Siege and Outnumbered 58-1 On January 6th. Notably, among other revelations, Sund’s book details “An exposé of critical intelligence and military failures surrounding January 6 and the subsequent attempts to cover them up.”[33]

These critical intelligence sharing omissions and others did not allow the responsible law enforcement authorities, i.e. the USCP and the DCNG to adequately prepare for and rehearse responses to large, unruly crowds that flooded the Capitol grounds and some entering the Capitol building. In view of all the above facts, the appointment of the January 6th Committee by Nancy Pelosi and the integrity of its subsequent investigation has been questioned by many. Steps need to be taken immediately to ensure transparency of all agencies’ official preparations and actions.

What Can be Done Immediately?

In addition to the USCP, Secret Service and FBI, the Senate and the House of Representatives leadership; Leader McConnell, Leader Schumer, Speaker Johnson and Minority Leader Jeffries, the Senate and House Sergeants at Arms and the collective membership need to come forth with the following unified and unequivocal actions and message:

· There will be ZERO TOLERANCE for any disruption during the transfer of power and for any official post-election events ow and in the future.

· This official position needs to be unanimous and declared applicable nationwide;

· Enlist the media outlets to convey this message to the nation;

· Prepare pre-recorded messages for dissemination to the public;

· For the Metropolitan DC area—The DCNG, DC Mayor Muriel Bowser, the DCPD, the Arlington Police Department, and USPP will partner with the USCP and the Secret Service and craft Memoranda of Understanding (MOUs) and devise an integrated plan(s) based on prior events held on the Mall;

· Establish a clear, chain-of-command communications approval process among the Chief of the USCP, the DCNG and the respective Pentagon leadership to minimize any troop and other responder deployment delays to the Capitol/contiguous areas for crowd control needs;

· Provide dedicated and tested communication links to the National Threat Assessment Center (NTAC) to facilitate immediate intelligence and incident reporting from all law enforcement sectors, local, state and federal;

· Provide dedicated communication links with the FBI/Behavioral Threat Assessment Center to monitor terrorist threats and Russian, Venezuelan and migrant gang activity; and

· Establish consensus among law enforcement agencies via MOUs for timely information sharing of protest and/or riot planning and critically— response criteria and notifications.

Collectively these recommendations and the following examples underscore the critical need to implement effective integration and transparency during security planning for government sponsored events, especially MOU’s. The January 6 Select Committee proceedings did not include fair, bi-partisan representation. Subcommittee investigations into the committee’s findings and the DoD’s handling of their response to the Capitol riots uncovered evidence that show the following:[34]

· Thousands of hours of video footage taken at the Capitol on January 6th were hidden and some destroyed;

· Several key witnesses were not included or their testimony was not included in the January 6 Committee inquiry.

· “Liz Cheney colluded with “star witness” Cassidy Hutchinson without Hutchison’s lawyer’s knowledge.”

· The DoD intentionally delayed the deployment of DCNG troops when urgently requested;

· The DoD IG intentionally failed to disclose evidence contradicting their false conclusions;

· The actions of the highest senior DoD officials, i.e. Secretary of the Army’s failure to honor the DCNG repeated deployment requests;

· The DCNG were prepared, ready and able to respond with a timely deployment;

· The Secretary of the Army falsely stated to Congressional leadership that he told the sheltering Members of Congress: “We have the greenlight. We are moving” at 3:18PM; and

· The DCNG in fact did not leave the Armory until 1700 (5PM).[35]

The recommendations cited below by Senator Gary Peters need to be institutionalized and implemented now and for future events. [36]

  • Conduct internal after-action reviews on the intelligence collection, analysis, and dissemination processes in the lead-up to January 6th;
  • Improve FBI and I&A policies, guidelines, and procedures for collecting, analyzing, and disseminating intelligence to partner agencies;
  • Improve inter-agency coordination for significant events and consider designating a lead federal agency; and
  • Responsibly reassert Congressional oversight authorities over the Executive Branch.

The State of the Secret Service – Can it be Saved?

A serious concern that January 6, 2021 brought into focus, and more recently with the two assassination attempts of Trump in July and September of 2024, is the competence of the Secret Service. Directly connected is its relationship with the intelligence agencies and the Biden Administration. Equally troubling is the lack of protective resources, i.e. experienced protective agents, counter-sniper teams, technical security teams, counter-surveillance and intelligence teams and worse—weak leadership—have profoundly hampered the Secret Service mission. In addition, Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) policy initiatives, excessive demands to staff 35 protective details (for a variety of government officials), lack of mandated training, diluted hiring practices and very low morale have exacerbated the agency’s problems.

Today’s Secret Service finds itself in the midst of a cauldron of divisive issues that has been boiling in recent years. Given this, it is critical to identify strategies and plans to improve its protective competence and get ahead of any post-election potential unrest with growing domestic and foreign threat levels. This may prove to be a herculean task since successful mitigation is predicated on open and coordinated bipartisan support. This may be a naïve goal given the division in the nation’s populous, even now, post-election. It appears the basis of the contention up to the election and now, despite the clear Trump election victory, was to beat Trump. Now many Democrat leaders are vowing to sabotage the Trump administration’s proposed initiatives. Many Democrat representatives, current and former government officials (and former intelligence officials) have stated this through media outlets. With the upcoming Inauguration of President-elect Trump, these facts need to be addressed now and beyond the Inauguration into the next four years of the Trump administration.

These factors and others continue to affect the effective protective operations of the Secret Service.

Considering these circumstances and alarmingly, two assassination attempts, the identification of Iranian assassination plots coupled with the recent operational failures of the Secret Service to implement basic protective security measures—their mission capability will require profound changes.

Reports continue among the Trump detail security agents, whistleblowers and former President Trump and now President Trump, the FBI has selectively and slowly released assassination plot and other threat information to the Secret Service. This has created distrust between the FBI and the Secret Service. On October 26, 2024, Business & Politics (BPR) reported “the DHS Office of Inspector General (OIG) admitted to Senator Grassley the DHS has a troubling history of obstruction, which Grassley cited as a “major red flag” for oversight.” Violations of the Whistleblower Protection Enhancement Act (WPEA) are also being reported.[37] Other disturbing whistleblower reports allege “Acting Secret Service Director Rowe ‘blocked’ OIG auditors from reviewing former President Donald Trump’s security protocols.” [38]

Most disturbing, there is evidence of mistrust within the Secret Service ranks. For its mission to survive, the leadership must be overhauled, top to bottom. It will require a thorough assessment to redefine its mission and test its capability in the face of the emerging threats from enemy states. This cannot be accomplished in-house.

Following the Capitol protests in 2020, USCP Chief Sund implemented a pro-active intelligence gathering approach but received no threat intelligence by the FBI, Secret Service, DHS and DCMP. Sund stated “there was no indication that a well-coordinated, armed assault on the Capitol might occur on January 6.” This assessment was based on intelligence or the lack thereof provided to Sund. On January 4th and January 5th, Sund hosted two intelligence meetings with the USCP Intelligence and Inter-Agency Coordination Division and with a dozen of the top law enforcement and military officials from Washington, D.C., including the FBI, U.S. Secret Service and the National Guard.[39]

Sund stated: “During both meetings, no entity, including the FBI, provided any intelligence indicating that there would be a coordinated violent attack on the United States Capitol by thousands of well-equipped armed insurrectionists.”

In the DHSIG’s Final Report: The Secret Service’s Preparation for, and Response to, the Events of January 6, 2021 dated July 13, 2024, by Joseph V. Cuffari, Ph.D., the Inspector General reported intelligence failures and policy related operational failures.[40] Six recommendations were made to improve preparedness between the Secret Service and the USCP. A few have been met.

The burning question—with this backdrop, how can the Congress and law enforcement officials adequately rely on intelligence agency reporting, the current administration’s support (or the lack thereof) and media reporting to prepare for potential disruptions in 2025? To effectively prepare for Inauguration Day, the Secret Service should establish specific and stringent MOUs with the FBI and the I&A to ensure they share timely and thorough intelligence impacting their protectees and NSSE’s in the future. This was not done prior to January 6, 2021. Further, security planning with the USCP and the DCMP, should include ongoing collaboration with military counterparts. This includes the DCNG and the DCMP to expedite crowd control responses. Critically, an agreed upon communications (tested) protocol among these agencies is required.

It has been observed by many law enforcement authorities the Secret Service is operating under a flawed threat model, i.e. a 1960’s era lone assassination threat. Today’s Secret Service has not fully embraced emerging technologies. The agency has not studied terrorist threat methodologies to see its benefit in varying environments.

The Secret Service published the <a href=”https://www.secretservice.gov/sites/default/files/reports/2023-01/usss-ntac-maps-2016-2020.pdf”> Secret Service Threat Assessment Centers Mass Attacks in Public Places Guidance in January 2023 through its National Threat Assessment Center (NTAC). This guidance focuses primarily on behavioral threat assessment metrics based on meta-data gleaned from 173 shooting attacks. It appears this guidance is not consistently followed in the current protective training model. The current training model is based more on reactive threat responses rather than proactive threat identification. Very little, if any study and/or training focuses on terrorist pre-attack behaviors i.e. recognizing and mitigating Islamic radicalization, attack planning (target selection, probing, testing), the purchase of precursor bomb making materials and countering multi-coordinated attacks.

Matthew Crooks clearly defeated the Secret Service at its own game. How is this possible? Are the Secret Service advance procedures too canned, too predictable? Strategic planning organizations in the public and private sector, especially in high threat environments, employ Red Team planning. At a basic level this means considering the adversary’s perspective and attack plan. Protectors should simulate attacks as an adversary would and fortify against them with security planning. In other words, wear two hats—your “good guy hat and the bad guy hat.” This is fairly obvious to seasoned military planners and strategists, However, since this strategy appears to be absent from the security planning where two assassination attempts occurred in Pennsylvania and Florida in 2024, it requires review. In simple terms…advance planners need to ask themselves: If I were a shooter or bomber, how would I identify the security plan’s vulnerabilities? What weakness would I exploit? Security planners need to ask what are we doing to fix them? This needs to be an evolving, on-going process. The Army does this on a continuing basis.

There is no evidence the Secret Service conducts any substantive Red Team exercises. The irony is Crooks, the would-be assassin who shot at Trump in Butler, PA and Ryan Routh, who attempted an assassination from a sniper position along a fence line at the Trump International Golf Course at West Palm Beach, FL, conducted better pre-attack planning than the Secret Service’s protective (counterattack) advance security team. Routh’s ability to get within easy shooting range, and remain virtually undetected for12-hours, exposed many other security operational weaknesses. To be clear both assassination attempts, one an actual AK shooting and one pre-empted, were catastrophic failures. This is a jolting and tragic wake-up call. Crooks’ and Routh’s budgets were probably less than $500 respectively. The Secret Service Presidential Campaigns and NSSE budget is reported to be ~$73.3 million from the Office and Management and Data. Clearly the security failures are not due to a lack of money.

What if the attacks at Butler or West Palm Beach had been planned by well-trained terrorists using multiple, simultaneous attack methods as witnessed in the series of coordinated Islamist terrorist attacks on Friday, 13 November 2015 in Paris, France? The Secret Service and the IC at large should be acutely focused on the possibility of diversionary, multitargeted attack scenario planning prior to the Inauguration (or any future major event). There are many analyses of asymmetrical attack methods that should be studied. Other salient examples include Mumbai (2009), Brussels (2016) and Barcelona (2017). DHS has published planning guidance to identify and prevent Complex Coordinated Terrorist Attacks (2018). Would the Secret Service be able to detect an attack plan like these let alone respond to them?

Since the 9/11 attacks billions of tax dollars have been invested in defense strategy revisions, police, military and emergency responder training, communications upgrades and field exercises to better equip all concerned to address evolving threats. The National Response Framework (2019) defines five core capacities to guide the training of the response community: prevent, protect, mitigate, respond, recover. The purpose is to “better integrate government and local response efforts.” Simply stated, all security partners need to focus more on prevention and work as a cohesive team. It appears these capacities were not incorporated in the security plan at Butler, PA or West Palm Beach, FL.

This guidance needs to be incorporated and operationally reinforced into all joint security efforts in the field; not only in training.

Agents from other DHS agencies sed to support Secret Service protective details should be required to meet the same protective training metrics required of Secret Service agents. The required training hours should be increased as outlined in the Secret Service Fiscal Years 2021-2025 Human Capital Strategic Plan.

The Secret Service needs to redefine its protective mission. The current policies and procedures are based on dated threat models. The old threat models guiding the Secret Service culture are myopic and limit creative thinking. More effective proactive strategies, policies and training that match evolving attack methods are needed:

· Move the Secret Service back to the U.S. Treasury Department;

· Re-examine basic security procedures;

· Recognize and respond to lone shooter profile behaviors;

· Incorporate Red Team planning and training;

· Review lone shooter and coordinated terrorist attack methodologies;

· Develop security advance training to include preventive and deterrent attack strategies;

· Require the IC to proactively and thoroughly brief the Secret Service PID and protective details with ongoing and timely protectee threat intelligence;

· Develop specific integration protocols with public safety counterparts;

· Require a Secret Service supervisor, partnered with the local jurisdiction law enforcement supervisor, to review the security advance Incident Action Plans (IAPs) and visit each site to be visited prior to the protectee’s arrival.

· Conduct post event hot washes and train to correct missteps;

· Partner with elite military forces, i.e. Delta and Seal teams to revise a range of protective measures and training;

· Reinstate annual physical medical screening with a coronary emphasis;

· Reinstate mandatory quarterly physical fitness testing for all gun carrying personnel;

· Develop scalable protective training based on emerging attack methodologies with a terrorist focus; and

· Specifically study and create protective training scenarios that identify terrorist simultaneous attack planning targeting routes, site access/egress locations, command posts, agent and law enforcement personnel staging areas and respective equipment.

Equally troubling, the recommendations set forth by the 435-page U.S. Secret Service: An Agency in Crisis from December 2014 (after serious security failures prompted this inquiry) as of this writing, have yet to be fully implemented. Conspicuously absent among them remains—the failure of protective detail agents to complete consistent training—“at least 12% of work hours by fiscal year 2025.” According to Jason Chaffetz, the agency has woefully failed to achieve this training target. He says the Secret Service has been on notice since 2015 to implement effective changes, namely training and accountability to prevent the failures. Many key recommendations have not been met.[41]

The collective observations and recommendations outlined above are further delineated, along with others, in the FINAL REPORT OF FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS completed by the Task Force on the Attempted Assassination of Donald Trump, dated December 5, 2024. This report was issued by Chairman Mike Kelly (R-PA) and Jason Crow (D-CO).[42] These recommendations should be prioritized with elite military forces. Establish scalable protective survey plans that can effectively adapt to changing locales and environments.

The world of team sports provides a compelling metaphor for how games are won. Team members are assigned positions based on ability and experience. They rehearse their plays incessantly until they get it right. Success in the protective security arena requires the same focus.

If the Secret Service team expects to win their zero-fail mission, they will need to rebuild a foundation of trust—first. Leadership deficits, disparate experience levels, inconsistent training, dated technology and other security advance omissions are fixable. Restoring trust among their fellow agents and with their brothers and sisters in blue and critically with their prized asset—the protectee—poses their biggest challenge. Winning is impossible without trust.

Is the Country Being Effectively Protected by its Intelligence Agencies?

To fully answer this, a hard look at the intelligence agencies and their successes and failures need to be critically examined in 2025. There have been more than 70 successful terrorist interdictions since 9/11. Unfortunately there has been an increase of serious failures in the last eight years, many preventable, in the homeland that dilute these successes. Many observers and media outlets are reporting partisan politics has rendered the agencies responsible for investigating and preventing many attacks in the past four years less proactive and less effective. Congressional committees and Inspectors General reports conducted in response to whistleblower testimony and media reporting have shown the FBI reallocated its resources from its primary mission to protect the nation from domestic and international terrorism. Their focus has shifted from cyber-threats, organized crime, violent crimes, human trafficking etc. to lesser crimes with a political bent. This shift in focus by the FBI along with collaboration with DHS has added to the rise of Domestic Terrorism.[43] According to the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) there has been a 357% increase in domestic terrorism from 2013 – 2023.[44]

After the 9/11 attacks on September 11, 2001, a candid review of the nation’s intelligence failures—contributing causes, i.e. agency information sharing dysfunction and the “siloed” structure of the IC; namely the CIA, FBI, NIA, DIA and the NSA was reviewed. The 9/11 Commission Report, released on July 22, 2004 examined these failures in detail.[45] Notably, the consensus finding was and unfortunately remains today—the intelligence agencies lack imagination and do not effectively share domestic and foreign threat information, particularly with a terrorist nexus. Bureaucratic and administrative restrictions delay the release of “sanitized” threat information that is in large part, not immediately useful by its consumers. Among the 9/11 Commission’s many recommendations—create a DHS in an effort to centralize 22 different federal agencies into one department. The intent was to unify security operations to be more responsive and less siloed in its handling of, sharing and responding to threat information to the homeland.

Unfortunately, this has not happened. DHS has been widely criticized for being stymied by bureaucratic dysfunction. Many have observed the amalgamation of the 22 agencies, in many cases, has had the opposite effect…these agencies, many of which with a more than a 100-year history, were not fully on board to “play in one sandbox” and share their tools risking the loss of their respective agency eminence.[46] As a result some argue many agencies hold onto information to be able to control investigations, justify funding, etc. Several studies show the goal of more effective information sharing has not been achieved despite the creation of several Presidential Directives enacted post 9/11 and the creation of more than 80 Joint Terrorism Task Forces (JTTFs).[47]

The numerous recent intelligence failures we are seeing and continue to experience is alarming. The conclusions of many Inspectors General reports and House Committee Hearings have further revealed the key intelligence agencies, CIA, FBI and others are not fully effective protecting Americans. It has been proven these agencies have been weaponized against conservatives and directly at Donald Trump and his family. This leads us to only one conclusion —our IC is broken. This is supported by the footnoted documents referenced in this writing. Among the many glaring facts: 51 former intelligence officials declared the Hunter Biden laptop, disinformation—later proven to be false. Further, the CIA admitted many of the 51 signatories were paid CIA contractors.[48] [49]

Several FBI, IRS and Secret Service whistleblowers including former FBI agents Richard Stout and Nicole Parker (and many others) have publicly called out the credibility of the FBI; specifically the leadership who have not prioritized the core mission of the FBI.[50] On December 9, 2024, Senator Grassley sent a letter to FBI Director citing as many as 60 examples of the FBI’s blatant failures to uphold the rule of law and obstruct the work of the Congress. The letter stated, “the FBI has shown an outright distain for congressional oversight during your tenure.”[51] Instead, recent FBI Directors, Comey and Wray chose to violate their oaths denying fair and due process rights to several hundreds of citizens and Brady rule violations for political purposes. Whistleblower testimony corroborates the FBI leadership, at many levels, were aware of this but continued this blatant dereliction of duty anyway.

It has been empirically shown the FBI and the DOJ, under the Biden Administration, have implemented an ongoing two-tier system of justice strategy targeting Republicans at large, prominent conservatives and Donald Trump while ignoring instances of clear federal statute violations (with undeniable probable cause) by the Democrats and leftists. “These include pay-to-play schemes by the Bidens and the Clintons.”[52] Not the least of which are the 18 instances of arson and vandalism targeting pregnancy resource and other faith-based centers by the group Jane’s Revenge which the FBI has not addressed.[53]

Basically, the FBI has shifted its focus and resources from counterintelligence, established terrorist threats, China hacking our nation’s IT infrastructure, sex trafficking of minors and organized crime to targeting Catholics, declaring parents attending school board meetings ”domestic terrorists,” investigating thousands of January 6th attendees and protesters and arresting pro-life demonstrators. Among the most egregious investigations and warrant executions was the unprecedented search of former President Trump’s residence, staging evidence and doctoring photos in August 2022 to justify prosecutions.[54]

Equally egregious, FBI failures identified by Senator Grassley included serious threats posed by foreign actors treated with tepid urgency if at all. For example, the FBI did not thoroughly vet Afghan evacuees under the Operations Allies Welcome (OAW), at least 50 of which were later flagged with “potentially security concerns.” This and the “open border” policy of the Biden administration, the dilution of ICE resources, restricting ICE’s arrest and deportation enforcement purview, defunding the police and weak enforcement of crimes committed by a high number of migrants entering the U.S. illegally has increased the nation’s vulnerability.[55] On June 25, 2024, DHS identified more than 400 crossed the U.S. border with an ISIS-affiliated network.[56]

Another disturbing example of the egregious failures and unlawful government oversight is documented in Senator Ron Wyden’s (D-ORE.) recent release of documents confirming the NSA and the FBI are unlawfully purchasing Americans’ internet browsing records and personal data.[57]

Restoring faith in America’s intelligence agencies to prevent what we have witnessed for at least the last eight (8) years will require significant reforms.[58] Essentially, there is a call for more transparency and bi-partisan oversight across the board.[59] Various national polls reflect more than 60% of Americans do not trust the government—especially the FBI.[60]

The GAO found the greatest number of domestic terrorism attacks are committed by either racially or ethnically motivated violent extremists, (this includes homegrown violent extremism) many of whom have been radicalized since 2010.[61] A few notable examples include:

· May 3, 2024 – Two Jordanian foreign nationals attempted to force their way onto Marine Base Quantico. Both were in the country unlawfully;

· May 9, 2024 – Trevor Bickford of Maine received a 27-year prison sentence for attempting to kill police officers in Times Square in 2022. He claimed he wanted “to wage Jihad and kill as many targets as possible;” and

· June 9, 2024 – 8 Tajikistan nationals were arrested in New York, Philadelphia and Los Angeles with ties to ISIS plotting terrorist attacks in the U.S.

Recent intelligence failures are compounded by disjointed inter-agency information sharing, fewer proactive responses to threat intelligence, poor monitoring of social media posts and not responding to credible law enforcement reporting. A key policy failure is the open U.S. border and restricting the Border Patrol’s ability to identify illegal crossings and account for “gotaways.” Collectively, these intelligence failures have led to increases in a wide range of crimes as follows:

· A resurgence of terrorist attacks;

· Human trafficking;

· Drug trafficking;

· Attacks targeting law enforcement officers and their equipment;

· Homegrown violent extremism;

· Lone wolf attacks at mass gatherings;

· Hate crimes;

· Attacks on churches;

· Active school shooter attacks;

· Attacks on family planning centers; and

· Cyber-attacks/Ransomware attacks.

Fixing this will require honest, bipartisan commitment. The IC, above all, will need to be accountable to their staffs and the American people. The proposed remedies (some of which cited below) are required to ensure the respective intelligence agencies are transparent with the appropriate federal and local law enforcement agencies. This is needed to prevent a repeat of the abuses identified earlier that targeted a variety of individuals and groups by the Biden administration.

· Establish a special bipartisan committee with full access to all intelligence and threats to ensure proportional decisions and actions to protect the homeland are made above politics and reviewed before being implemented;

· Ensure the investigations conducted by the intelligence agencies are strictly within their jurisdictional purviews;

· Assess the effectiveness of the collaborative sharing information practices and formal agreements between the FBI and DHS. A 2023 GAO study shows threat information is not shared effectively by them and is not immediately useful. This GAO report identified a key reason for this serious information sharing dysfunction:[62]

“FBI officials told us they did not use the data DHS collects on domestic terrorism incidents because they weren’t aware DHS was collecting it. DHS officials in turn told us they didn’t share their incident data with their FBI counterparts because they weren’t asked for it.”

· Verify that any unmasking follow CIA & FBI rules. The names of many U.S. citizens were improperly released instead of or with foreign targets;[63]

· Enact strict verification processes to prevent using circular reporting by “creating” false and damaging information, leaking it to the press and then opening investigations based on that. It has been established the FBI under Director Comey and other FBI officials engaged in this practice; and

· Enact strict adherence to verification processes to ensure the basis of any Section 702 Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) application requests are factual. Rampant abuse of the FISA process by Director Comey and other FBI officials (from 2016 – 2017 and beyond) has been confirmed by the DOJ IG.[64]

On December 9, 2019, Attorney General William Barr stated the DOJ IG determined the evidence put forth to the FISA Court to secure warrants to surveil the Trump campaign and his administration “were not factual, omitted consistently exculpatory information.” AG Barr further stated: “ The malfeasance and misfeasance detailed in the Inspector General’s report reflects a clear abuse of the FISA process;”[65] [66]

Looking Forward

As we begin 2025 and we assess the state of our government, the state of our safety, the state of our security, our sovereignty and most important, America’s pre-eminence on the planet; now is a great opportunity to work to rejuvenate the bedrock principles that make us the sterling example of freedom and strength. It is possible to reignite the nation’s status as the “Shining City on a Hill” as President Reagan described it.

It will take an honest commitment for the new Trump administration to set things right. In the last several years many of our agency heads and politicians put egos and politics ahead of the nation’s guiding principles. How many of them were boy scouts and forgot the first point of the scout law?: “A scout is trustworthy.” How many attended military academies and committed to the credo?: “A cadet shall not lie, cheat, steal or tolerate anyone the does.” How many swore allegiance to the United States and their Oath of Office (5 US Code Sec. 3331)?: “I do solemnly swear I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic…I take this obligation freely without purpose of evasion…”

If there was ever a time in the history of our nation when accountability, honest introspection and reform is critically needed…it is NOW!

[1] https://www.gpb.org/news/2024/10/21/law-enforcement-officials-prepare-for-possible-post-election-violence-in-dc

[2] https://www.govexec.com/federal-news/2024/10/law-enforcement-officials-prepare-possible-post-election-violence-dc/400374/

[3] https://www.nytimes.com/2024/11/16/us/politics/democrats-anti-trump-battle-plan.html

[4] https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cj6kj383k4ko

[5] https://www.politico.com/news/2024/11/08/donald-trump-iran-assassination-plot-00188498

[6] https://www.cnn.com/2024/10/24/asia/russia-china-north-korea-iran-new-axis-intl-hnk/index.html

[7] https://thehill.com/opinion/criminal-justice/3671392-nearly-half-of-the-country-now-has-serious-doubts-about-the-fbi-heres-why/

[8] https://nypost.com/2022/03/18/intelligence-experts-refuse-to-apologize-for-smearing-hunter-biden-story/

[9] https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/elections/2024/12/14/biden-trump-laws-judges-regulations-legacy/76865964007/

[10] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2024/10/28/the-us-spies-who-sound-the-alarm-about-election-interference

[11] https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2024/02/democrats-congress-trump-january-6/677545/

[12] https://americanmilitarynews.com/2024/08/video-democrat-congressman-calls-for-civil-war-conditions-to-disqualify-trump-if-he-wins/#google_vignette

[13] https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2024/10/20/trump-overturn-2024-election-plan-00184103

[14] https://www.politico.com/news/2024/11/20/democrats-trump-foes-governors-attorneys-general-interest-groups-00190177

[15] https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/campaigns/presidential/3238783/shell-shocked-democrats-struggle-mount-resistance-trump/

[16] https://www.nytimes.com/2024/10/22/us/politics/election-warning-russia-iran.html

[17] https://www.odni.gov/files/ODNI/documents/assessments/NICM-Declassified-Foreign-Threats-to-US-Elections-After-Voting-Ends-in-2024.pdf

[18] https://www.dhs.gov/publication/special-event-assessment-rating-sear-events-fact-sheet

[19] https://oig.justice.gov/sites/default/files/reports/25-011.pdf

[20] OIG-24-42-Aug24-Redacted copy.pdf

[21] https://www.peters.senate.gov/newsroom/in-the-news/peters-report-details-failures-ahead-of-jan-6-attack-calls-for-changes

[22] https://www.newsweek.com/ex-capitol-police-chief-sounds-alarm-jan-6-cover-1817365

[23] https://www.npr.org/2021/03/03/973292523/dod-took-hours-to-approve-national-guard-request-during-capitol-riot-commander-s

[24] https://www.npr.org/2021/01/11/955548910/ex-capitol-police-chief-rebuffs-claims-national-guard-was-never-called-during-ri

[25] https://cha.house.gov/press-releases?ID=1E353E41-4087-428A-A477-B70E5FD46FA1

[26] https://www.peters.senate.gov/newsroom/in-the-news/peters-report-details-failures-ahead-of-jan-6-attack-calls-for-changes

[27] https://www.peters.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/peters-report-finds-significant-intelligence-failures-by-fbi-and-dhs-in-lead-up-to-january-6th-capitol-attack

[28] https://www.hsgac.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/230627_HSGAC-Majority-Report_Executive-Summary_Jan-6-Intel.pdf

[29] https://www.oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/assets/2022-04/OIG-22-29-Mar22-Redacted.pdf

[30] https://cha.house.gov/_cache/files/2/2/22c7bff3-c7be-4ba9-b539-767ec0fda0ac/DA74D6968E28C88C7160A0ED12148C84.11.21.2024-loudermilk-dod-ig-letter.pdf

[31] Letter from Chairman Charles Grassley, Se. Comm. on Fin., to Director Wray (Dec. 9, 2024), https://www.grassley.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/grassley_to_fbi_-_failures.pdf

[32] https://taskforce.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/july13taskforce.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/12-5-2024-Final-Report-Redacted.pdf

[33] https://www.blackstonepublishing.com/blogs/news/former-capital-police-chief-steven-a-sund-set-to-publish-a-new-book-about-the-attack-on-january-6-with-explosive-never-before-revealed-information

[34] https://cha.house.gov/press-releases?ID=1E353E41-4087-428A-A477-B70E5FD46FA1

[35] https://cha.house.gov/2024/12/chairman-loudermilk-releases-second-january-6-2021-report

[36] https://www.peters.senate.v/newsroom/in-the-news/peters-report-details-failures-ahead-of-jan-6-attack-calls-for-changes

[37] https://www.bizpacreview.com/2024/10/26/whistleblowers-claim-secret-service-employees-working-with-trump-were-made-to-sign-ndas-1497932/

[38] https://nypost.com/2024/10/09/us-news/secret-service-blocked-watchdog-to-hide-inconsistent-security-protocols-at-trump-events-whistleblower/

[39] https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/capitol-police-chief-steven-sund-entire-intelligence-community/story?id=75729882

[40] https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/dept.-of-homeland-security-oig-releases-report-on-secret-service-s-response-to-jan.-6-attack-on-the-u.s.-capitol

[41] https://oversight.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/Oversight-USSS-Report.pdf

[42] https://taskforce.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/july13taskforce.house.gov/files/evo-media-document/12-5-2024-Final-Report-Redacted.pdf

[43] https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-23-104720-highlights.pdf

[44] https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-23-104720

[45] https://9-11commission.gov/report/911Report_Exec.pdf

[46] https://www.thoughtco.com/department-of-homeland-security-4156795

[47] https://www.congress.gov/117/meeting/house/114425/witnesses/HHRG-117-JU08-Wstate-JonesS-20220217.pdf

[48] https://www.newsweek.com/hunter-biden-laptop-jim-jordan-facebook-disinformation-twitter-1767369

[49] https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/cia-admits-some-signatories-of-hunter-biden-laptop-letter-were-paid-contractors/ar-BB1oVNjs

[50] https://ijr.com/richard-stout-how-to-reform-our-politically-weaponized-fbi-and-restore-public-trust/

[51] Letter from Chairman Charles Grassley, Se. Comm. on Fin., to Director Wray (Dec. 9, 2024), https://www.grassley.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/grassley_to_fbi_-_failures.pdf

[52] https://thehill.com/opinion/criminal-justice/3671392-nearly-half-of-the-country-now-has-serious-doubts-about-the-fbi-heres-why/

[53] https://www.foxnews.com/politics/zero-arrests-16-janes-revenge-attacks-pro-life-organizations

[54] https://www.foxnews.com/politics/house-judiciary-committee-investigates-alteration-evidence-seized-fbi-trump-classified-records-probe

[55] https://www.dhs.gov/news/2024/10/02/dhs-2025-homeland-threat-assessment-indicates-threat-domestic-and-foreign-terrorism

[56] https://homeland.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/CHS-10.3.24-Terror-Threat-Snapshot.pdf

[57] Senator Ron Wyden (D-ORE.) recent report by Ars Technica states the NSA has admiied to buying records

[58] https://www.thecipherbrief.com/column_article/the-intelligence-community-is-broken-heres-how-we-fix-it

[59] https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/restoring-america/courage-strength-optimism/3224584/how-trump-can-intelligently-reform-the-intelligence-community/

[60] https://thehill.com/opinion/criminal-justice/3671392-nearly-half-of-the-country-now-has-serious-doubts-about-the-fbi-heres-why/

[61] https://www.gao.gov/blog/rising-threat-domestic-terrorism-u.s.-and-federal-efforts-combat-it

[62] https://www.gao.gov/assets/gao-23-104720-highlights.pdf

[63] Lt. General Flynn and other Trump administration officials were improperly unmasked during 2016 – 2017.

[64] Section 702 authorizes targeted foreign intelligence information collection related to terrorism. U.S. persons may not be targeted and their names indiscriminately used without a specific nexus to terrorism.

[65] https://clayhiggins.house.gov/2019/12/09/higgins-ig-report-confirms-obama-era-fbi-abused-fisa-process/

[66] https://thehill.com/policy/national-security/4012650-fbi-misused-surveillance-tool-fisa-section-702/