Skip to content

Arizona Dems’ Immediate Priority: Cover Tracks

Cover image of Seth Keshel's article on Arizona ballot harvesting

The rumor mill gives insight proving my assessments correct

Rachel is still a member of the Arizona House of Representatives until early January. She remains connected to bits of information not readily available to the outside world until what they have to say hits the airwaves, newspapers, or podiums manned by official mouthpieces of the state government. Yesterday, we got a doozy of a notification:

Democrats are planning to run a bill repealing the law forbidding ballot harvesting.

If you want a crash course on what ballot harvesting is, read the article below highlighting its implementation in California over the past decade, with Orange County used as an example (it’s free for all to read):

Mail-in balloting is now popular in purple and blue states for several reasons:

• It guarantees a high floor of ballots. The hallmark of Obama’s 2010 and 2014 blowouts was piss-poor turnout everywhere, but especially in urban slums with high minority populations; those voters are the least likely to turn out in a midterm environment, especially when the president’s star power has faded or the party’s brand is in the toilet. Making sure a ballot lands on every table for every registered voter gets more votes in the box than leaving voting up to individual motivation to show up at a polling center.
• When harvesting is in the mix, the people doing the harvesting have weeks to pursue those ballots that are now sent out, and they are often fully authorized to “incentivize” the surrender of those ballots (hand them over for a gift card) or even go so far as to selectively ask for ballots of the voters most likely to return a favorable (Democrat) ballot – like the 18-year-old in the household who otherwise wouldn’t vote if not compelled otherwise to do so.

The scam, once fully grown, also takes advantage of filthy voter rolls. We got a great example out of New Jersey this year, when Governor Sherrill tried to get out ahead of a massive scandal by revealing what is certainly the tip of the iceberg only:

This is why purple and blue states love to implement Automatic Voter Registration at the first opportunity. Remember how they voted in 2024?

Chart of 2024 electoral votes in states with and without Automatic Voter Registration

That’s right – Trump won 248 out of 253 electoral votes not under Automatic Voter Registration, while losing electoral votes under that system almost four to one. I had a special chapter in The American War on Election Corruption highlighting how the corruption of the voter roll merges with expanded mail-in voting (Universal Mail-In Voting is the desired end state) to produce Democrat ballot counts that can only be explained by explicit changes in the law and the work of boots-on-ground ballot harvesters.

In summary, to fully streamline elections to favor Democrats, this is what Democrat legislatures like to do (with a trifecta including the governor):

• Universal Mail-In Voting (or as much mail-in voting as possible)
• Automatic Voter Registration
• Ballot harvesting legalization (or at least a neutral position, such as that found in Pennsylvania)

It’s not technically cheating when you put it in the law, right? Therein lies the problem – and the fact that so many blue states make laws like this should help you understand why I didn’t overestimate any Democrat in my forecasts this year. This is no different than when it wasn’t illegal to take steroids in Major League Baseball, but once it was discovered that the 1990s had the insane home run totals it had only because the game’s top stars were on the juice, their records were no longer held in high regard. They were tainted, and many will never reach the National Baseball Hall of Fame. So it is with these insane ballot totals – they are inorganic and turn elections into a cheap knock-off more closely resembling the redemption of coupons at the grocery store than a contest to receive the most legitimate votes.

Here is the law Arizona Democrats will need to repeal to take the first step to Nevada-izing Arizona’s already awful elections:

Text of Arizona Revised Statute 16-1005 on ballot abuse

Note the rich irony in the description of this law being “ballot abuse.”

ASSESSMENT OF LEGISLATIVE ACTION

You just can’t make this shit up. I’d love to say I’m surprised, but Democrats actually use their political capital when in office. They don’t care if they’re outnumbered by almost 300,000 in voter registration; they will line up in the goal line formation, run it down your throat, and laugh about it while telling you you’re a conspiracy theorist for pointing out that these bastards cheat like hell.

Florida, Texas, Georgia, Arizona, and a few other states, consider ballot harvesting beyond approved standards (like turning in the ballot of a family member) a felony. Other states, like Washington, Oregon, California, and Nevada, have fully legalized the process and have essentially destroyed the concept of free-and-fair elections by doing so. Any Republican winning a statewide election in a state like that (such as Trump carrying Nevada in 2024), does so by having his side redeem more ballots than the other, and will need a legitimate groundswell of voter support to even be in position to out-harvest the other side.

So, back to Arizona Revised Statute 16-1005. My guess is that they won’t fully legalize ballot harvesting. I think they’ll leave it in a gray area. Previous Democrat bills under GOP-run legislatures kept penalties for buying/compensating for ballots in place, and Democrats will almost certainly make any changes to this law about stopping “voter suppression” of whatever nonsense their pink-haired staffers pull from an AI server as justification. In summary, I expect Democrats to alter ARS 16-1005 to remove criminalization language from the law, or perhaps strike the whole thing and rewrite something else to cover a few of the bases so the easily duped Maricopa moderates who stab the GOP in the back “buy in.”

WHAT NOW?

There are two “good news” items here:

1. I am confident Democrats have been doing this since at least 2018, when they installed Katie Hobbs as Secretary of State after her GOP opponent had been called the winner on Election Night – and when Martha McSally lost to Kyrsten Sinema in the race for U.S. Senate. Check out the Democrats’ presidential vote totals from 2004 through 2016, all losing efforts:

• 2004 893,524
• 2008 1,034,707
• 2012 1,025,232
• 2016 1,161,167

Then look what they became capable of after learning how to cheat even in the face of record GOP vote gains:

• 2020 1,672,143
• 2024 1,582,860

Democrats went from being hard-pressed to gain 140,000 net new ballots for a generational candidate like Barack Obama to increasing by more than a half-million in a single race for Biden’s fraudulent 2020 win in the state (+10,457 ballots).

This means any Democrat action on ARS 16-1005 is likely to cover their tracks and effectively make all of their cheating in a 75% mail-in balloting state legal. Read my assessment of how obvious the ballot harvesting is in Apache County from 2020, and how I can spot a fraudulent margin that would have put Trump over Biden statewide by fixing just Apache and Navajo Counties alone:

2. If ballot harvesting becomes legal, or falls into a gray area of permissibility, then Arizona will become the most prominent political battleground with both a heavy mail count and notable GOP voter registration advantage:

Arizona voter registration totals by party from the Secretary of State

There are, as of the latest Secretary of State update, 283,483 more Republicans than Democrats in Arizona. Independents here lean left, and Maricopa County and parts of Pima County have a significant count of Flake-aligned Republicans who have steadily backstabbed the party in the age of Trump, allowing Democrats to mitigate their voter registration disadvantage. However, Mohave, Yavapai, and a few other counties are loaded up with major GOP-aligned populations that can then be approached by any means necessary within the confines of whatever ARS 16-1005 becomes.

Groups like Turning Point USA, which have been “chasing” mail-in ballots (making frequent contact with low-propensity voters to persuade them to get their ballots in) will no longer be bound by the law and can then adopt tactics to successfully harvest Republican votes rather than hope their chase targets follow through with voting. On a personal note, I recognize how much this cheapens the electoral process – even if my side wins. But absent major federal reforms or court rulings with nationwide implications over mail-in balloting practices, there is no option other than to adapt and overcome. In states like Washington, Oregon, and California, Republicans lack the manpower and registrations to do this without a major realignment putting the wind at their backs. In Nevada, elections can and have been won recently by GOP candidates; in Arizona, with a much more favorable political disposition than Nevada, there will exist an opportunity to upend this corrupt mail-in balloting system if, and only if, Republicans set aside the infighting and organize by the numbers to defeat an aggressive and determined enemy unafraid to use its legislative power – even in its first trip back to such power in 60 years.

Seth Keshel, MBA is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy and a retired Army Captain. He publishes Captain K’s Corner on Substack.

Related Articles