Skip to content

Gaza – “Just War Doctrine” and Israel’s War on Hamas

IDF soldiers uncover a Hamas tunnel shaft in Gaza

This article was written by Ernie Audino and appeared in Frontlines of Freedom. GAZA – “JUST WAR DOCTRINE” and ISRAEL’S WAR on HAMAS.

There’s no shortage of breathless talking heads criticizing the Israeli ops to eliminate the Hamas terror threat in Gaza. Many of them insinuate/assert that Israel’s war on Hamas is somehow unjust. Many (if not most) of these talking heads have neither wartime military experience nor professional experience with the Hague and Geneva conventions, which apply.

The Conventions incorporate Just War Doctrine as articulated by St. Augustine in the 5th Century. Of the several tenets of Just War Doctrine, the big three are Just Cause, Proportionality, and Discrimination.

Just Cause – Per the doctrine, war can be just if it’s defensive or waged to right a grave injustice.

Proportionality – Per the doctrine, the application of military force must be enough to achieve the military objective or defeat the threat, but no more. This tenet is widely misunderstood, however. Many wrongly assume that military force must be proportional to the adversary’s military force or to balance the harms…an eye for an eye, so to speak, i.e. “The enemy killed 1,200 of us, so we can only kill 1.200 of them.” This is a fundamental misunderstanding and couldn’t be further from the truth.

Discrimination – Per the doctrine, parties to war must discriminate combatants from noncombatants. Civilians must be protected from intentional targeting. Targets must be legitimate, military targets. All reasonable measures must be employed to protect civilians, but collateral civilian deaths are expected and tragic. Unintended civilian deaths do not necessarily make the war unjust.

So, let’s apply these to the IDF ops to destroy the Hamas threat in Gaza.

Does Israel have a Just Cause? Yes. The Hamas atrocities of 7Oct provide indisputable justification for Israel’s counterattack and the ongoing military effort to eliminate all continuing threat of re-occurrence. No reasonable person can argue otherwise.

Is Israel’s response Proportional to the objective of eliminating that threat? Yes. The Hamas attack on 7Oct was made possible by a preceding 21 years of terrorist stockpiling of arms & ammunition, 21 years training specifically to kill non-combatants, 21 years to build its manpower to 30,000+ fighters, most intentionally arrayed within civilian neighborhoods, schools, hospitals, mosques, and of course, deep within a network of 500 kms of tunnels, most of which were intentionally emplaced beneath civilian infrastructure. It took Hamas 21 years to build all the above. Only a serious effort can dismantle it.

• Against Hamas (and by my best count), the IDF presents a peak of 14 IDF brigades engaged in active ops at any one time on the ground in Gaza. So, at 4,000 troops or so per brigade, that totals to roughly 56,000 on the ground at any one time to confront the 30,000 Hamas terrorists. The ratio of IDF to Hamas on the battlefield is not even 1.9:1. That’s WAY below the 6:1 force ratio historically considered optimal for offensive operations, AND that’s even below the 3:1 force ratio considered minimally acceptable for offensive ops.

Do IDF ops discriminate combatants from non-combatants? Yes, and to extremes I’ve never personally experienced on the battlefield. For example, in advance of each, specific operation, the IDF makes phone calls and sends texts to the families and households in/near the objective and warns them of the upcoming operation. It directs them toward safe zones established for their relocation. The IDF uses loudspeakers, radio announcements and leaflets for the same purposes. And the IDF has postponed or delayed kinetic ops until all reasonable efforts to remove civilians from the target area had been exhausted. So, what are the numbers?

• More than 42,000 phone calls
• More than 4,000,000 leaflets
• More than 12,000,000 recorded messages
• More than 15,000,000 texts

And keep in mind, every time IDF commanders issue these warnings in advance of upcoming ops, they are wittingly assuming additional risk upon themselves. As a matter of pure military logic, no commander in his right mind would choose to disclose his upcoming ops. We call it OPSEC (Operational Security).

So, do your own analysis, and don’t rely on headlines.

We discussed all of the above and more on the show this week. My guest is British Army Colonel (ret) Richard Kemp. You’ve likely seen him on TV or in the news. He’s a Commander of The Order of The British Empire and recipient of the Queen’s Commendation for Bravery. He has led troops everywhere from Northern Ireland to Bosnia to Iraq to Afghanistan, and he’s recently spent a fair amount of time inside Gaza. He knows of what he speaks. Click on the link to hear our discussion: https://frontlinesoffreedom.com/show-983/

Illustration of St. Augustine and the tenets of Just War Doctrine: right intention and discrimination
Written by Ernie Audino Senior Military Fellow, Gold Institute for International Strategy
Related Articles