Skip to content

2026 Ten-Point Forecast: WI-3 (U.S. House – Decisive)

Wisconsin's 3rd Congressional District race: Derrick Van Orden vs. Rebecca Cooke

Derrick Van Orden (R-inc.) vs. Rebecca Cooke (D)

I. The Race

WI-3 candidates Derrick Van Orden and Rebecca Cooke

Derrick Van Orden (Republican) is a retired Navy SEAL and small business owner who flipped WI-3 in the 2022 Republican House takeover. He defeated his 2026 opponent in 2024 by a margin of +2.7% and is currently seeking a third term in the U.S. House.

Rebecca Cooke (Democrat) makes her third run at WI-3 after having lost the Democrat primary in 2022 and to Van Orden in 2024. She is aiming for the proven Wisconsin Democrat platform of “salt of the earth, moderate, boring midwestern white woman” that has won them one seat after another on the State Supreme Court, emphasizing her dairy farm roots.

II. District Geography

Map of Wisconsin's 3rd Congressional District

Wisconsin’s 3rd Congressional District (WI-3) is a massive district. It stretches from the outskirts of Minnesota’s Twin Cities all the way to the Illinois state line, and halfway across Wisconsin. It contains all or parts of 19 counties, including Democrat leaners Eau Claire and La Crosse Counties, which together make up over 30% of the population. WI-3 has traditional Democrat undertones and only began to trend Republican under Donald Trump and the MAGA movement’s success with the white working class. The problem with WI-3 this year is that Trump isn’t on the ticket. Pay attention to the transformation of the southwest quadrant of Wisconsin from Obama’s 2008 statewide win all the way through Trump’s 2024 win:

County map of the 2008 presidential election in Wisconsin
2008 Presidential Election in Wisconsin
County map of the 2024 presidential election in Wisconsin
2024 Presidential Election in Wisconsin

Trump’s tremendous progress in WI-3 was instrumental in his 2016 flip of Wisconsin, his 2020 should-have-won campaign, and his 2024 recapture. Here are the presidential margins in today’s boundaries:

Presidential Margins

Table of presidential margins in WI-3 under today's boundaries

On all three occasions, Trump ran ahead of the GOP nominee for U.S. House. Trump’s presence on the ballot is important for getting these voters to turn out and change sides, given that they all widely supported Obama twice.

Key Statistics

89.1% White, 3.3% Hispanic

56.9% Rural, 43.1% Urban

Market Assessment

Polymarket bettors are behind Cooke, valuing her shares at 77 cents each.

IV. History

Ron Kind, a blue dog Democrat from La Crosse, won the open WI-3 seat in what was then a rare Democrat victory in the district. He held the seat for more than two decades, surviving the 2010 and 2014 Republican waves and even running uncontested in 2016, when Trump won the state. After a close call against Van Orden in 2020, with a margin of just +2.7%, a whiff of the pro-Trump trend in the district plus a view of a coming 2022 Republican House popular vote victory were enough to get Kind to call it a career. Van Orden took the open seat by a margin of 3.7%:

2022 WI-3 House election result

Cooke had lost the 2022 Democrat primary to Brad Pfaff, but she won it in 2024 for the right to challenge Van Orden. Riding shotgun with Trump, he held his seat:

2024 WI-3 House election result

His margin was +2.7%, just 11,256 votes. He ran 4.2% behind Trump’s margin in the district. Having won the seat twice, once in a House popular vote midterm and again in a presidential win of Wisconsin, Van Orden finds himself facing headwinds for the first time in 2026, and in a similar position such as the one Kind found himself in looking at 2022.

V. Analysis of 2026 Primary Results

Van Orden ran unopposed this year for the GOP nomination. Cooke prevailed over Emily Berge, taking 60.0% of the vote.

2026 WI-3 Democratic primary result

Cooke and Berge had a contentious primary, which included Berge accusing the Democrats of buying the race for Cooke, but things seem to have been smoothed over.

VI. Polls

These polls were pulled from The New York Times:

Table of WI-3 polls

Nothing new since June, when Cooke was leading Democrat internals by 4.

VII. Media Ratings

Media ratings of the WI-3 race

Three of four major reviewers consider the race a “toss-up,” while Decision Desk is super bullish on Cooke.

VIII. Party Registration

Wisconsin does not register voters by party; however, in nearby IA-1, which features a very similar Obama-to-Trump electorate, Republicans have added to the raw GOP advantage, while giving a little ground on the overall percentage thanks to more non-affiliated voters in the electorate:

Party registration trend in IA-1

It is likely the overall disposition of the electorate closely resembles the one that voted in 2024.

IX. Election Considerations

Wisconsin, which lacks Automatic Voter Registration, uses same-day voter registration as a loophole to increase the state’s voter roll by as much as 10% on Election Day alone. While this has limited impact in a rural district like WI-3, it completely reshapes the conversation due to the impact it has on late ballot dumps in Milwaukee and Dane County.

X. Summary and Election Estimate

Van Orden, winner of two narrow contests held under favorable conditions (a House popular vote win in 2022 and a presidential win in 2024), now tests the waters when there is a Democrat headwind and a tenacious challenger hoping that the third time is a charm. I think this is a very hard-fought race with polarizing factions squaring off, which essentially turns it into a battle of turnout between the rural counties and La Crosse/Eau Claire Counties, which will lean hard for Cooke.

This is how my decision matrix looks:

Keshel's ten-point decision matrix for WI-3

I called “money” a tie because while Cooke has raised about one-third more than Van Orden, she has far less on hand than he does here in the stretch run. The most concerning early sign for Van Orden is that La Crosse County is ranked 8th of 72 counties in percentage of its 2024 presidential vote already cast (with Eau Claire 18th), while Van Orden’s rural strongholds lag far behind, with 9 counties ranked at 50th or worse.

I think this year’s headwinds and the nature of WI-3’s “Trump or bust” disposition renders Cooke a clear favorite, although not inevitable.

Forecast for WI-3 House

Keshel's forecast for the WI-3 House race

Seth Keshel, MBA is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy and a retired Army Captain. He publishes Captain K’s Corner on Substack.

Related Articles