2026 Ten-Point Forecast: New Hampshire U.S. Senate

2026 Ten-Point Forecast: New Hampshire U.S. Senate

John Sununu (R) vs. Chris Pappas (D)

I. The Race

New Hampshire U.S. Senate candidates John Sununu and Chris Pappas

John Sununu (Republican) is from the well-known Sununu political family of New Hampshire, and once held the exact Senate seat he’s seeking in 2026. He won it in 2002, but lost it to Jeanne Shaheen in the 2008 Obama wave. Shaheen is now retiring, prompting Sununu’s latest run.

Chris Pappas (Democrat) is the sitting U.S. House Representative for NH-1, a seat he won in 2018 and has defended three times since. Despite New Hampshire’s competitive disposition, Pappas is largely focusing his campaign on “get Trump” themes, which may backfire on him given his opponent’s clout.

II. State Profile

New Hampshire state profile map

The Granite State is, by far, the most conservative of the six New England States. Like Maine, it was once a GOP stronghold; it voted for all but six Republican presidential nominees from 1856 through 1988, but has only backed one (George W. Bush, 2000) since then. Still, it generally elects Republican governors and surrounds them with GOP legislatures and plays an oversized role in early primaries.

New Hampshire is overwhelmingly white, and like its neighbors, has rural progressivism. These folks love their land and tolerate the guns, but aren’t down with the southern brand of evangelical influence that drives the modern Republican Party. This was obvious in the lopsided 2008 and 2012 presidential setbacks; however, Trump’s push in 2016 focused on the opioids epidemic and piqued the interest of New Hampshire’s white working class voter base. Strangely, the state’s two most populous counties (Hillsborough and Rockingham), situated along Massachusetts’ northern border, are the keys to Republican wins and are substantially more conservative than many counties in the state’s interior. New Hampshire, presidentially speaking, votes well to the left of its voter registration advantage, signifying frustrating levels of GOP crossover to Democrat federal candidates and the left-leaning nature of unaffiliated voters.

Key Statistics

88.3% White, 4.3% Hispanic, 2.6% Asian

III. Market Assessment

Polymarket transactions have Pappas as the 89% favorite; he is definitely overpriced on this market, despite the dynamics of a Trump midterm.

IV. History

In the 2002 midterms, one of the few since 1934 to have favored the president’s party, Sununu defeated Shaheen by 4.5% for this exact seat:

2002 New Hampshire U.S. Senate result, Sununu over Shaheen

In 2008, Barack Obama won the Granite State by double digits; Sununu performed better than John McCain, but this time dropped the seat to Shaheen by 6.3%. She has successfully defended it twice, in 2014 and 2020. It drifted right from the 2012 presidential election with standard midterm dynamics in 2014, and she won her race over Scott Brown, former U.S. Senator from Massachusetts by 3.2%. She won her last race in a blowout, more than 8 points left of Biden’s win over Trump.

In the other seat, the one occupied by Maggie Hassan, the 2022 midterm featured a blowout despite Biden occupying the White House. The GOP nominated Brigadier General (USA, Ret.) Don Bolduc, and he went on to lose by 9.2%.

2022 New Hampshire U.S. Senate result, Hassan over Bolduc

Hassan first won the seat by an eyelash in the 2016 election from Kelly Ayotte, who extended a streak of GOP dominance stretching back to 1981 when she first won the seat in the 2010 wave. With Ayotte’s ouster, New Hampshire normalized its U.S. Senate seats to its standard presidential disposition – blue, but not overwhelmingly so.

In 2002 and 2022, New Hampshire Senate seats favored the president’s party by margin shift. In 2010 and 2014, they blew against it. This means that Trump’s presidency gives Pappas no guarantee of a margin to the left of Harris’s +2.8% mark from the 2024 presidential election.

V. Analysis of 2026 Primary Results

Both Sununu and Pappas prevailed over primary challengers.

New Hampshire 2026 Republican U.S. Senate primary results

Sununu faced off against Brown, and won by +42.0%. Brown immediately congratulated Sununu, putting an end to any possibility of party drama impacting the General Election race negatively.

New Hampshire 2026 Democratic U.S. Senate primary results

Pappas, on the other hand, has had drama with DSA-aligned challenger Karishma Manzur, who still has not fully endorsed Pappas, though she says she opposes Sununu and Trump. Pappas, looking to earn her support (worth a third of the Democrat primary vote), has been overly accommodating to her. This rift matters, because statewide races in New Hampshire often come down to mere thousands of votes.

VI. Polls

RealClearPolitics polls for the New Hampshire U.S. Senate race

The RCP average has Pappas up by almost 7 points, with all polls making up that average affording him a minimum lead of 5 points. Sununu had some tied or narrowly leading polls after the primary, but those are in the distant past at this point. I will note that some of the pollsters listed above have had a number of wild misses (especially St. Anselm).

VII. Media Ratings

Media ratings for the New Hampshire U.S. Senate race

Inside Elections appears to have done some homework on New Hampshire Senate races and isn’t buying into polling showing a runaway race. The other three outlets give Pappas the edge.

VIII. Party Registration

New Hampshire party registration changes since 2024

In the long run, things are positive for the GOP. They have moved the state more than a half-point to the right since Trump’s close finish in 2024; however, they’ve also dropped nearly 10,000 net registrations since the state’s summer update, which can be directly attributed to the state’s primary prompting voters to pick a party. Democrats jumped from 247,069 registrants in June to 255,943 in September. Factoring in the fact that independent voter behavior is a known commodity in the state, this may be like shifting change from one pocket to another – but it does suggest momentum for Pappas.

IX. Election Considerations

Here is what I had to say about vulnerabilities:

Opportunities for Election Manipulation

Two good things positioned New Hampshire for a competitive race in 2024. The first was the aforementioned voter roll purge that cut lots of fat out of the credit line for absentee cheating, and the second is the state’s lack of Automatic Voter Registration, which is a key hallmark of a blue state (New Hampshire is the only state without AVR that Harris won in the 2024 election, meaning Trump carried non-AVR states 248 to 5 in the Electoral College). There are two key issues that remain for election integrity measures:

• Voter ID – Republican Governor Chris Sununu signed a Voter ID bill this year, but not in time to have it take effect before this year’s election. This is a commonsense reform with major national support that must be seen through to ensure basic voter fraud cannot occur, especially with New Hampshire’s well-known same-day registration loophole present.

• Same Day Registration – This issue destroys election integrity in many other states, and has been known to taint New Hampshire’s close elections, such as has long been suspected in the case of Hillary Clinton’s 2,736-vote victory in 2016. The two densely populated counties along the Massachusetts state line, Rockingham and Hillsborough, are particularly vulnerable to out of state bad actors providing false identifying or qualifying documents and casting ballots in high numbers. This must be eliminated to ensure election security.

Relative to other states, New Hampshire doesn’t have a lot of issues. But Kelly Ayotte and Donald Trump both lost the state in 2016 by margins requiring very little manipulation.

X. Summary and Election Estimate

New Hampshire, despite Republican statewide dominance, has been stuck in a Democrat rut for federal elections since expelling Ayotte in 2016. Trump has had two close calls in the state, but most of the electorate comes from two urban counties near the Massachusetts line.

Sununu, thanks to his family name and experience, probably enjoys a boost of a few points on those factors alone. New Hampshire sometimes moves toward the president’s party in midterms, but it hasn’t done that for Republicans this century. The race looks like this in terms of key factors:

Ten-point decision matrix for the New Hampshire U.S. Senate race

Sununu has a significant edge in outside spending over Pappas, but Pappas has done better with individual contributions – which matches the momentum in registration changes from independents from the primaries. Scott Brown, who won a special election for U.S. Senate in Massachusetts in 2009, was a strong candidate, but Sununu’s name ID gives the GOP a shot in this race a generic Democrat wouldn’t have.

Forecast for NH Senate

For the reasons listed above, and with the expectation that some of Trump’s affluent New England voters from 2024 will defect, my forecast looks like this:

Forecast for the New Hampshire U.S. Senate race

Seth Keshel, MBA is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy and a retired Army Captain. He publishes Captain K’s Corner on Substack.

2026 Ten-Point Forecasts: FL U.S. Senate and Governor

Florida U.S. Senate and governor forecast graphic

Ashley Moody (R*) vs. Angie Nixon; Byron Donalds (R) vs. David Jolly (D)

I. The Races

U.S. Senate

Florida U.S. Senate candidates Ashley Moody and Angie Nixon

Ashley Moody (Republican) was appointed to replace Marco Rubio in the United States Senate after he (Rubio) became Secretary of State under Trump 47. Moody had previously been Florida’s Attorney General, most recently winning her second term by +21.2% in 2022. She now faces a special election required by state law.

Angie Nixon (Democrat) is a DSA-aligned politician with three terms in the Florida House of Representatives. She shocked everyone by winning the Democrat nomination against Alexander Vindman in the August primary.

Governor

Florida governor candidates Byron Donalds and David Jolly

Byron Donalds (Republican) is the GOP nominee for governor after serving three terms in the U.S. House representing FL-19 (southwestern Florida). He is seeking to continue the reforms of Governor Ron DeSantis, under whom Florida has transformed into a powerful red state.

David Jolly (Democrat) is the latest former Republican to turn Democrat and seek the governorship, following Charlie Crist. Crist lost a close election to Rick Scott in 2014, and was absolutely annihilated by DeSantis in 2022. Strangely enough, Jolly served parts of two terms in the old FL-13, before being ousted by Crist in 2016.

II. State Profile

Florida state profile map

Most Captain K’s Corner readers remember Florida as an absolutely vital presidential swing state with a GOP-lean for statewide offices. Florida was so critical for Republican hopes that no GOP nominee for president made it to the White House without carrying Florida since 1924. Thanks to the rise of Donald Trump, and the governorship of Ron DeSantis, the days of Florida as a bellwether and swing state are long gone.

Florida presidential election margins

Florida is more than R+11% by registration, won by Trump at a margin of 13.1% in 2024, and receives new movers who are reported to be R+40% in their partisan disposition. Combined with the realignment of the Latino voting coalitions (primarily Venezuelan, Cuban, and Puerto Rican in Florida), the Sunshine State is a near-impenetrable red fortress. Republicans, unlike their timid counterparts in Texas, have been viciously attacking Democrat strongholds, and in several instances are turning them red.

Key Statistics

51.5% White, 26.5% Hispanic, 15.1% Black

III. Market Assessment

Polymarket bettors have better vibes about Moody’s campaign against Nixon, but Donalds is also heavily favored to win the governorship.

IV. History

U.S. Senate

Past statewide races and partisan trends are typically useful guides for races like these, but Florida has become so red, the distant past resembles another state entirely. The state hasn’t had two Democrat U.S. Senators serving simultaneously since Bob Graham and Bill Nelson served simultaneously from 2001 to 2005, when Graham retired. Mel Martinez (Republican) was elected in 2004 to replace Graham, but resigned before his term was over and was replaced by George LeMieux, who finished the term and gave way to Marco Rubio.

Rubio served until his appointment to Secretary of State, winning reelection on two more occasions. In that span, Nelson was ousted by Rick Scott in a 2018 upset. Since 2019, Florida has been represented by two Republicans in the U.S. Senate and has seen their reelection margins increase drastically.

Governor

Despite its swing state status, Florida has preferred Republican governors exclusively dating back to the end of the 20th century, when Jeb Bush was elected (1998). Bush was reelected in 2002, then gave way to Crist in 2006. Crist vacated the office in 2010 and was replaced by Scott, who won harrowing margins of +1.2% in 2010 and +1.1% in 2014 to keep the streak alive. Perhaps the most important gubernatorial win of the century occurred in 2018, when DeSantis defied the polling odds and inched past Andrew Gillum:

Florida 2018 governor result, DeSantis over Gillum

Florida was less than 33,000 Democrat votes away from electing a drug addict living a reckless lifestyle instead of the governor who turned them into the next Texas. DeSantis had been without hope until Trump endorsed his candidacy, and then overcame absolutely clueless polling to beat Gillum:

Polling in the 2018 Florida governor race

Since the modern Florida GOP made it out of the stormy waters, it has been smooth sailing.

V. Analysis of 2026 Primary Results

U.S. Senate

Moody took on a few primary challengers, but won her primary with 79.6% of the vote. The real primary drama took place over on the Democrat side, when Nixon stunned Vindman:

Florida 2026 Democratic U.S. Senate primary results, Nixon over Vindman

If you’re sitting around worried about what a bunch of polls say, the one poll I found on the Democrat primary had Vindman up by 10.0%. He lost by almost 12 points. Vindman, logically speaking, is a hated figure in Florida because of his role in targeting President Trump – the Republican leader at the time of Florida’s ascent to red stronghold.

Poll of the Florida 2026 Democratic U.S. Senate primary

While no one disputes the legitimacy of Nixon’s primary victory, her radicalism and ties to DSA-aligned groups will alienate the moderate baby boomers who supported Vindman and voted for Joe Biden in 2020.

Governor

Florida 2026 Republican governor primary results

In a crowded field full of big names, including the sitting Lieutenant Governor (Collins) and former speaker of the Florida House of Representatives (Renner), as well as an insurgent fanning the flames of Gen Z resentment (Fishback), Donalds rode Trump’s endorsement to a comfortable win. While Donalds has his detractors, DeSantis is now behind his campaign and he shouldn’t be missing any key GOP coalition.

Florida 2026 Democratic governor primary results

Jolly won an easy majority in another crowded field, and there is no reported Democrat drama surrounding his win.

VI. Polls

U.S. Senate

RealClearPolitics polls for the Florida U.S. Senate race

The RCP average of polls has Moody up 7, although St. Pete Polls is sandbagging her a bit with their recent +2.

Governor

RealClearPolitics polls for the Florida governor race

With fewer polls making up the gubernatorial average, Donalds is up 5. Like Moody’s race, he’s held down a notch by St. Pete Polls. Notably, both Moody and Donalds are +11 in the most recent Stetson University poll.

VII. Media Ratings

U.S. Senate

Media ratings for the Florida U.S. Senate race

None of the major reviewing bodies think Moody is in any trouble.

Governor

Media ratings for the Florida governor race

While none of them have Donalds on the hot seat, they’re leaving the window open for Jolly to close the gap.

VIII. Party Registration

Florida party registration changes since November 2024

What’s the biggest mountain in the way of the Nixon/Jolly pairing? Look no further than party registration. Remember when I mentioned that new transplants to Florida are reportedly R+40% in their partisanship? The numbers above seemingly confirm this.

Republicans have netted a gain of 439,197 voters since Trump carried the state by 13.1% less than two years ago. Nearly 300,000 of that net is from Democrat losses, but still roughly 140,000 of that comes from new GOP registrations. These gains are widespread, reaching all the way down to former Democrat strongholds in Miami. Florida’s transformation is truly astounding.

IX. Election Considerations

People frequently ask me which states have made the most important reforms to elections since the 2020 quasi election. “Florida” is my hands-down answer. Governor DeSantis signed Senate Bill 524 in 2022, creating the election crimes task force and ensuring that the state would have proper control over mail-in balloting (requiring voters to request a ballot and confirm the address the ballot would be sent to). While it is a large state full of opportunities to attempt fraud, it has done an incredible job at preventing mass fraud.

Notably, Florida sets the “gold standard” for counting millions of ballots, nearly the entire statewide count, by the time people wake up the next day. They learned how important public trust in elections is after the 2000 “hanging chads” debacle and have set the standard for the rest of the country.

X. Summary and Election Estimate

Florida is already running to the right of its final 2024 mail balloting return splits, and now the fake pollsters are quietly moving away from the Sunshine State. These two elections aren’t coming down to “who” will win, but by how much the Republican candidates will win by. The decision matrices tell the tale:

U.S. Senate

Ten-point ratings matrix for the Florida U.S. Senate race

Governor

Ten-point ratings matrix for the Florida governor race

Thanks to Florida’s efforts to secure elections, the overwhelming growth of the Republican coalition, and a national atmosphere that has soured on the Democrat brand, these are two of the most obvious predictions out there.

Forecast for FL U.S. Senate

Forecast for the Florida U.S. Senate race

My 99/1 rating for Moody is to essentially state that I see zero path for Nixon. It wouldn’t surprise me if Moody, thanks to Nixon’s insane radicalism, wins by more than 20 points. The bigger question I have is whether or not Moody will win every county.

Forecast for FL Governor

Forecast for the Florida governor race

Donalds is also essentially a lock. To believe Floridians would watch the state clear R+11% by registration and even think about handing the keys over to the party they’ve completely abandoned defies logic. Donalds won’t have Moody’s numbers because Jolly is at least a real candidate, but I’d expect a margin in at least the low double digits.

Florida is a unique phenomenon, and we should all invite Democrats to waste funds there.

Seth Keshel, MBA is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy and a retired Army Captain. He publishes Captain K’s Corner on Substack.

2026 Ten-Point Forecast: CA-48 (U.S. House – Decisive)

2026 Ten-Point Forecast: CA-48, Jim Desmond vs. Marni von Wilpert

Jim Desmond (R) vs. Marni von Wilpert (D)

Author’s Note: This forecast/prediction contains proprietary mapping data beyond the paywall information prepared by the author for analytical purposes.

I. The Race

CA-48 candidates Jim Desmond and Marni von Wilpert

Jim Desmond (Republican) has served two terms on the San Diego County Board of Supervisors. He’s a Navy veteran and is focusing his campaign on ensuring borders remain secure and policing crime and drug activity, which is rampant in urban California.

Marni von Wilpert (Democrat) is essentially the reverse image of Desmond. She’s a member of the San Diego City Council, and runs the standard female “get Trump” campaign focused on vague positions like healthcare and affordability, and more nefarious efforts to handcuff ICE and restrain them from fixing the city she’s helped ruin.

II. District Geography

Map of California's new 48th Congressional District

California’s 48th Congressional District (CA-48) is newly drawn and facing the first election held under its new boundaries. The current CA-48 is held by Darrell Issa (Republican), who won by 18.6% in 2024 and is retiring instead of dealing with the new boundaries.

The new lines dodge conservative areas in northern San Diego County and run northeast in Riverside County to include Palm Springs, a hippie Democrat stronghold with huge margins. President Trump made a lot of progress within these boundaries in 2024, but still fell short against Kamala Harris.

Presidential Margins

Presidential margins within the CA-48 boundaries

Key Statistics

53.3% White, 29.4% Hispanic, 6.9% Asian

III. Market Assessment

Polymarket bettors are sticking with the California Democrat home team and expecting their all-mail elections to get von Wilpert over the top.

IV. History

There is no precedent for swing and election outcomes in the district as it will be drawn for this election; however, in the first Trump midterm including Palm Springs (then in CA-36), the swing favored the GOP from 2016, swinging right by 6.2%. Raul Ruiz had won in 2016 by 24.2%.

Past election swing in the Palm Springs area district

Still, most of the swing in margin came from outlying areas of the district, which stretched east to west across California and deep into the desert.

V. Analysis of 2026 Primary Results

CA-48 2026 jungle primary results

Desmond came in first in CA-48’s jungle primary format with 38.9% of the vote. Von Wilpert doubled up the next closest Democrat and won her party’s nomination with just 20.8% of the vote. While Desmond beat von Wilpert handily, this is how the two-party voting looked:

Republican 45.8%
Democrat 53.3%

If there is reason to hope Desmond has a shot in this race, it’s because von Wilpert and Ammar Campa-Najjar (the third place finisher in the primary) had a meltdown drama-fest between special interest pets. Von Wilpert was accused of Islamophobia and racism, while Campa-Najjar was deemed a misogynist and homophobe. Sheesh – all is not well when that wretched coalition comes into conflict with itself. The primary outcome favors Desmond and gives him perhaps his lone advantage over von Wilpert.

VI. Polls

I pulled these polls from The New York Times:

CA-48 polls from The New York Times

On average, von Wilpert leads by 6 points.

VII. Media Ratings

Media ratings for the CA-48 race

All major reviewing bodies favor von Wilpert, ranging from “tilt” to “likely.”

VIII. Party Registration

I cannot access or calculate party registration splits dating back to November 2024, when Kamala Harris carried the new boundaries by 3.0%, but I do have the current figures as of September 4, 2026:

Democrats 171,370 (37.01%)
Republicans 148,932 (32.16%)
Total 463,047

Lead D+4.9% (D+22,438)

This marks an increase for Democrats, up from D+4.4% (D+20,292) on April 3.

IX. Election Considerations

It will come as no surprise that California is the gold standard for Democrat election laws. I have written extensively about the topic this year with regard to their primaries, and wrote about all of the third-world ways they rig elections in the Gold State in my 2024 evaluation of their election:

California’s Universal Mail-In Voting and legalized ballot harvesting, in addition to the many weeks of ballot counting they are permitted to do, provide an emergency safety mechanism for any Democrat stuck in a close race. Von Wilpert benefits tremendously from this point.

X. Summary and Election Estimate

This seat stands to become much more competitive by the time the Democrats are forced to redraw maps at the end of the decade. Trump’s close finish required a lot of movement with Latinos, which are likely to regress in their share of Republican support in a Democrat favorable midterm.

The proprietary mapping here, sponsored by patriot Shannon Lawrence, shows the challenge to Desmond:

Captain K proprietary precinct mapping of CA-48
Captain K Proprietary Mapping of CA-48

Rural San Diego County is red turf, but it is held in check by the purple jumble in the western portion of the county, particularly to the east of Carlsbad. Western Riverside County remains a GOP stronghold, but it is cancelled out and then surpassed by Palm Springs and the surrounding cities of the Coachella Valley with the only “Democrat” (Trump below 30%) precincts in the entire setup. California Democrats sharpened their pencils when drawing these maps. Desmond needs pitiful turnout in Palm Springs and to hold most of Trump’s Latino gains to have a shot.

My ratings matrix shows a decisive advantage for von Wilpert:

Ten-point ratings matrix for CA-48

California primary statistics since they’ve moved to the jungle format give us a greater idea of how things are going to shake out. Consider:

California jungle primary statistics compared with general election results

Democrats almost always exceed their combined primary vote shares, especially in races that aren’t absolute blowouts. There were 7 races in 2022 in which Democrats combined for less than 60 percent of the primary vote in and in which they lost ground in the General Election. There were 2 such races in 2024. The largest regression was -2.9% in CA-27, and that occurred in a GOP-favorable year.

If von Wilpert were to shed 2.9% of the cumulative Democrat primary share of 53.3%, she would still win with 50.4%. Desmond’s only hope is that the primary fissures for Democrats persist, and she loses more than 3.3% of the cumulative primary share. Ideally, she would need to lose a lot; Democrat ballot harvesters operate legally and are well-compensated.

This district will improve in the long run, at least before it is redrawn. Until now, it’s a tough mountain to climb.

Forecast for CA-48 House

Forecast for the CA-48 House race

Seth Keshel, MBA is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy and a retired Army Captain. He publishes Captain K’s Corner on Substack.

2026 Ten-Point Forecast: IA-1 (U.S. House – Decisive)

Mariannette Miller-Meeks and Christina Bohannan, the IA-1 House candidates

Mariannette Miller-Meeks (R-inc.) vs. Christina Bohannan (D)

I. The Race

The IA-1 candidates, Mariannette Miller-Meeks and Christina Bohannan

Mariannette Miller-Meeks (Republican) is running for a fourth term in the U.S. House, and has won two of her three terms by insanely close margins. She had previously run for the seat when it was designated IA-2, but lost to Dave Loebsack all three times she was the GOP nominee. She finally got in when Loebsack retired.

Christina Bohannan (Democrat) is a former Iowa State Representative who is nearly as persistent as Miller-Meeks; Bohannan has lost to her two times in a row, and is confident that the third time will be a charm this November.

II. District Geography

Map of Iowa's 1st Congressional District

Iowa’s 1st Congressional District (IA-1) is made up of the southeastern quadrant of the state. As you can see, it has undergone a drastic political reformation since 2008:

Map of the 2008 presidential election in Iowa by county
2008 Presidential Election in Iowa
Map of the 2024 presidential election in Iowa by county
2024 Presidential Election in Iowa

The district resembles northern Illinois and Wisconsin politically far more than it resembles Missouri or Nebraska, which influence the western half of the state. Obama carried the current boundaries by 16 points in 2008, and then by 14 in 2012 as Iowa inched toward Romney in a statewide loss. Here were President Trump’s margins:

2016 Trump +3%

2020 Trump +2.9%

2024 Trump +8.5%

The political hurdles for Republicans in the district, especially normal Republicans like Miller-Meeks without Trump’s white working class superpowers, are Johnson County and the University of Iowa (Harris +37.8%), and Scott County, which contains Davenport. Racial demographics appear favorable but there is a long-standing blue-collar Democrat faction here.

Key Statistics

83.4% White, 5.6% Hispanic, 4.5% Black

66.4% Urban, 33.6% Rural

III. Market Assessment

Ouch. Looks a lot like NE-2, with bettors not expecting much out of Miller-Meeks.

IV. History

Democrat Dave Loebsack secured one of the party’s biggest upsets in 2006, knocking off incumbent Republican Jim Leach. He went on to defend the seat six more times, which included three wins over Miller-Meeks (including one in which he beat her like a drum in 2008). Without Trump on the ticket in 2018, Loebsack expanded his margin by 4.8% from the previous presidential election:

Result of the 2018 IA-1 House race won by Dave Loebsack

Once Loebsack finally retired, Miller-Meeks came back into the picture and rode a Trump statewide win to a razor close victory over Democrat Rita Hart – a margin of just six votes out of nearly 400,000 cast.

Result of the 2020 IA-1 House race, Miller-Meeks vs. Rita Hart

Her first meeting with Bohannan occurred in the 2022 GOP House takeover, and Miller-Meeks rode Kim Reynolds’ incumbent coattails to a 6.8% margin. One might think that with Trump destined to win Iowa by more than 13 points and IA-1 by 8.5%, Miller-Meeks would have another easy election against Bohannan:

Result of the 2024 IA-1 House race, Miller-Meeks vs. Bohannan

That assumption would constitute a wild miss; Miller-Meeks secured her seat in a very narrow GOP majority by 799 votes out of more than 400,000 cast. She has won two of the closest U.S. House races this century in a span of just three elections. This does not bode well for her in a year that is fundamentally more favorable to Democrats than a cycle in which Republicans are out of the White House.

V. Analysis of 2026 Primary Results

2026 IA-1 primary results

Miller-Meeks took on a primary challenger who posted a respectable share (28.4%), and Bohannan took out her opponent easily. No lingering drama from the primaries persists.

VI. Polls

Polling data pulled from The New York Times:

IA-1 polls archived by The New York Times

The Bullfinch Group is to polling credibility what Nickelback is to fine music, but even a blind squirrel finds an acorn now and then. Bohannan leads by 4.5% in an average of the two polls I found.

VII. Media Ratings

Media ratings for the IA-1 race

Cook remains hesitant to take a stance on the race, but the other three favor Bohannan by various degrees.

VIII. Party Registration

IA-1 party registration change

This is a mixed bag. Because there are more total active voters registered in the district, the Republican lead as a percentage has fallen by 0.3% despite a gain in the raw lead. This likely tracks with independent sentiment dragging results to the left this year and favors Bohannan.

IX. Election Considerations

One thing is for certain, and that is that Iowa runs excellent elections. A lot of this is owed to the current treasurer, Roby Smith, who started turning the screws on election reforms as a state legislator before the 2020 election. Iowa has manageable early voting windows, control over the mail-in balloting process, and a voter registration system that doesn’t automatically register voters. You can read more about Iowa’s 2024 election quality in his Iowa – 2024 Election Compendium (December 24, 2024).

X. Summary and Election Estimate

Miller-Meeks is in a tough spot, and it makes sense why the Republican Party is triaging her race.

TRIAGE NEWS: The Congressional Leadership Fund and Trump’s super PACs are cutting off their first GOP incumbents in NJ-7 and IA-1 as the party races to avoid more widespread losses in final three weeks. Also giving up OH-1 and MI-8.

Shane Goldmacher (@ShaneGoldmacher), October 13, 2026

In examining all of the decisive seats, IA-1 leaps off the page as one of (if not the most) likely losses of the entire field. Miller-Meeks is an uncharismatic candidate with two “scraper” election wins in the past three races. The first, the win of just six votes, took place with Trump on the ballot. Her second win was propped up by Kim Reynolds winning a GOP-favorable midterm reelection race by more than 20. Her win in 2024 was by less than a point, with Trump winning the district with a Reagan-like performance.

Unfortunately, I think she’s toast. Here is my matrix to support the decision:

Seth Keshel's key factors matrix for the IA-1 race

Bohannan has made enough public comments to prevent the DSA scare from setting in. She has been critical of Biden on the border and sticks mainly to center-left Democrat reforms, realizing she’s in a Trump +8.5% district. Additionally, the district has a very white population, which is much more likely to turn out and vote and be pushed into the standard political winds of a midterm. This means there isn’t much of a low-propensity minority coalition here likely to sit out and give a huge hand to Miller-Meeks. The incumbent’s only hope here is for the University of Iowa to be completely checked out and have very little elasticity present in the MAGA coalition.

Forecast for IA-1 House

Seth Keshel's forecast for the IA-1 House race

Seth Keshel, MBA is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy and a retired Army Captain. He publishes Captain K’s Corner on Substack.

Four Things to Expect out of the 2026 Midterms – A 30,000’ View

Cover image for Seth Keshel's midterm overview, Four Things to Expect out of the 2026 Midterms

Three more weeks.

This is my first post in nearly two weeks that isn’t a preview of a key race for the House or Senate. Today’s piece will be brief, but open for all of my subscribers in full. I may release a voter registration update spanning the 2024 election to the 2026 midterm election when I have closed books, but unless something absolutely wild breaks out, I’m going to be writing forecasts as I receive more and more data.

For today, I’m going to give you the clearest possible look at what I see developing in the midterms at a 30,000’ level. Like when you’re on the airplane and the captain tells you the cruising altitude and the weather at your destination, that’s what I’m going for today.

Here are four baseline items you can expect out of the 2026 midterms:

I. The GOP Can Retain the House Majority

Emphasis on can. They are not the favorites to do so, because 92 years of midterms inform us that the president’s party faces massive headwinds. Those have manifested as an average loss of 27 seats, and losses in 20 of 23 midterms since 1934; however, far fewer districts are competitive thanks to redistricting in blue and red states alike, and the GOP narrowly won the redistricting war thanks to the late impact of the Callais decision.

Even with Callais, the Democrats had a shot to sail to a relatively smooth flip of the House, even if their ceiling yielded only a small majority (less than 225). What they’ve done, however, is squander some of the most obvious flips by nominating radical, DSA-aligned candidates. In a normal year, even without an overwhelming generic ballot advantage, they would flip MI-7 and CO-8 with ease, winning both by roughly five points. I have the GOP favored to hold MI-7, and essentially dead even in CO-8.

We will soon find out just how much money impacts the balance of power when it is coming in hot from the Republican side. Normally, the Democrats are the ones with the huge financial advantage. Not so much this year. Republicans have a lot of seats to defend in which incumbents are doing the defending – this is an advantage worth a couple points, at minimum. While history suggests losses for the president’s party in 87% of midterms since 1934, I think the Republicans have perhaps a 1-in-3 shot of holding the House. Even if they don’t, the math doesn’t look promising for Democrats to command a large majority.

Like the Electoral College, the House math comes down to 435 individually drawn seats, not a generic ballot advantage.

II. The Democrats Have the Uphill Senate Climb

Chart from Seth Keshel's 2026 Senate outlook

Just like the GOP can retain the House on paper, the Democrats can flip the Senate. It’s just not that easy, and the media are already hedging on the polls and their insane predictions that Democrats should be favored in four states Trump carried by over 11 points each.

Here’s how things go:

• Republicans have a 53-47 edge as things are today
• If Democrats flip North Carolina, that moves to 52-48
• Maine is a presidential blue state, but Collins is strong and likely to win, as I’ve profiled already – the Senate remains at 52-48 if this happens
• Democrats can hold Georgia, Minnesota, and New Hampshire (all likely), and even hold Michigan (toss-up), and still be down 52-48
• To get things to 50/50, they’d need to win two of Kansas, Nebraska, Iowa, Ohio, Alaska, or Texas
• Alaska may be a very dicey race for reasons I’ve profiled already, but the other states are formidable mountains and should help you understand why there is such a polling PSYOP underway

Senate races also behave more in line with presidential outcomes and feature far less volatility than House races. While the Democrats have a path, it’s most certainly not an easy one to navigate.

III. Tea Leaves

Many states have excellent reporting available in which analysts can observe mail-in balloting stats (like requests and returns) and in-person voting numbers. Georgia opens up in-person early voting today, and we will get a glimpse of enthusiasm that could tell us if Mike Collins has a shot in the Senate, or how the urban turnout in Atlanta that Keisha Lance Bottoms needs in order to become governor is shaping up. Data Republican has a great site with really cool trackers for Florida, Pennsylvania, and North Carolina.

Right now, early voting looks rough for Republicans in Virginia, but I am only monitoring VA-2, and possibly VA-1, as meaningful races. The media will cast this as a bad omen for the GOP, but what did we expect when the Trump 47 administration slashed the bureaucracy as promised? I warned of this in 2025 (and not a warning pleading not to do it).

Right now, Florida is not giving us a warning of a blue wave. There may be an indication of a blue undertow, which would be consistent with a standard midterm environment, but I’m less inclined to believe Republicans are heading for a reverse 1994 wipeout. Here’s data from Florida, from Data Republican’s page:

Florida mail-in ballot return data from Data Republican's tracker

Yesterday, mail-in ballot returns favored Democrats by 7.1% (43.0% to 35.9%). You can see that in 2024, all mail-in ballots favored Democrats by 7.0%. This is also what things looked like in 2022; now, this may relatively favor Democrats because Florida is now R+11.4%, nearly four points to the right of the 2024 election – perhaps the GOP should run closer to even if all things were set equal.

That may be your Republican headwind, or perhaps during in-person early voting, Republicans will slaughter Democrats even worse than normal. Miami-Dade County and Broward County are much redder on returns compared with previous cycles, which is a bad omen for Democrats in the new decisive seat, FL-25.

In other states in which early voting data can be analyzed, Democrats appear to have mobilization issues in Ohio, Wisconsin, and more states in the Midwest. If this manifests in Georgia, North Carolina, and Texas, Democrats will struggle more than their forecasts and polls let on.

IV. Media and Polls Will Still Lie

If the pattern holds up, media fluff and polling nonsense will persist all the way until Election Day. Right now, there is a major operation to cover for James Talarico, who disappeared for almost two weeks before magically reemerging in Austin on October 9. If you’ve been following that drama on X, it has been suggested he was in a mental facility in Ohio, which the clinic denied and the New York Times denounced. Here’s an actual sequence of events:

Talarico disappeared in the middle of a campaign he’s supposedly winning, when actually winning it would require a full sprint through the finish line to win by the smallest of margins imaginable. When this came under scrutiny, we were told he had “the flu.” None of us would be off of work for that long with the flu, and no campaign would have been ground to a halt over it.

Whispers emerged about the Lindner Center of Hope in Mason, Ohio, which Lina Hidalgo (Harris County Judge) had been admitted to in 2023. Perhaps this was a source in Ohio, or one in Texas, or maybe just drawn from the internet as a rumor. Nick Sortor released audio of a receptionist at the clinic searching for “Talarico” in the database and confirming a discharge date. The date in the system didn’t line up with Talarico’s appearance in Austin, but that doesn’t erase the fact that she gave the information.

The facility, that evening, broke its own confirm/deny policies to state that they hadn’t ever treated Talarico. The statement looked to be written by a lawyer with plenty of room for interpretation.

The New York Times, yesterday, revealed that they had been shown proof of security footage confirming Talarico was indeed at home in Austin. They agreed not to show the evidence to the public. So, essentially, we were told “trust us” by the facility and by the media, as Talarico was lying about where he received medical care in Texas (Dallas or Austin?) and in which type of treatment center he was seen (primary or urgent care?).

There is a recorded call, and then there are two “trust us” statements – one from the facility and the other from the media. Talarico’s supporters say the call was made with AI; how are we to know any security footage, if it exists, isn’t made or timestamped by AI? If President Trump were being accused of a major scandal and ran to the NYT with evidence against it, would the public accept “trust us?” What would the media have done had Paxton disappeared for two weeks?

I fear we have reached the point in society at which anything can be written off as “AI” and without 100% evidence of something – it never happened. I don’t know if Talarico was in the mental facility or not, but I can damn near assure you they have something other than “the flu” going on. Many key Democrats are lamenting his absence from the trail publicly and don’t buy the story either.

You will continue to see the media rush to defend Democrat candidates and prop up suppression polling until the end of the cycle. The best thing that can happen for everyone is for the mainstream polling industry to go belly up, and be drastically wrong about the outcomes of this election. There are a few good pollsters left and some read this newsletter, and they will be the first to admit that many unethical pollsters should be forever exiled from the industry.

Conclusion

There you have the 30,000’ view in a nutshell. It will be an interesting three weeks, but these elections will face familiar headwinds and constant factors, as they do in every race. Key events can swing them, but early voting is underway in most states and the data we receive each day informs what is, and is not, possible for either side.

Thank you all for your readership, and make sure to get out and vote, and bring as many friends and family members of like mind with you to the polls.

Seth Keshel, MBA is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy and a retired Army Captain. He publishes Captain K’s Corner on Substack.

Spies, Espionage & Intelligence – Life Is Like a James Bond Movie

Spies, Espionage & Intelligence: two men in overcoats exchange a package on a dark street

This article was written by Ernie Audino and appeared in Frontlines of Freedom. SPIES, ESPIONAGE & INTELLIGENCE – LIFE IS LIKE A JAMES BOND MOVIE.

I’ve had high-level security clearances for much of my career, but it wasn’t until late in my career when I was admitted to a specific handful of sensitive, compartmented programs that I sat back in my chair one day and whispered to myself, “Wow. This is really like a James Bond movie.” Colonel Chris Costa, US Army (Ret) lived in that black world, and now he is the Ex. Dir of our International SPY Museum in DC. He joined me on the show this week: https://frontlinesoffreedom.com/show-981/

A little context…with the exception of Israel, no other nation comes close to our technical means of collection capabilities. In fact, our collection capabilities are so good that the sheer quantity of information acquired through SIGINT, MASINT, COMINT, ELINT, GEOINT, IMINT, FININT, OSINT, etc.., can rapidly overwhelm us. As human beings, we can only consume so much. Key info gets overlooked in the noise.

The bigger challenge, however, is that we can become so enamored of technical collection methods, that we hamper the deeper understanding of human will. Understanding the WHY behind an enemy’s decision-making is no less important than the where/when/what the enemy has done or is capable of doing. We need to know HOW an enemy thinks, so to speak. What motivates him? What does he consider important? How does he see the world? How does he see himself?

This is why the best spies operate inside the enemy’s mind. They build rapport with potential intel sources and find ways to penetrate the enemy circle of trust. Their heads are inside the enemy’s culture. We will need more of this in the future.

Why? Because the enemy’s increasing employment of hybrid capabilities that intentionally target the gray zone between war & peace, and crime & combat, confuses us as to how to respond AND almost infinitely expands the range of potential threats requiring a response. So, a strategy based overwhelmingly on responding can never be enough.

That means placing more priority on engaging MUCH earlier in the enemy decision cycle. That means not waiting until we detect the enemy assembling the parts and pieces for a strike but rather disrupting his plan at its earliest point…ie when he first conceives of it in his mind. THAT requires a much more robust human intelligence effort and a much deeper understanding of human will. It will also require us to get comfortable with a military that is no longer purposed to just “Deter, Fight and Win,” but also to “Deter, Fight, Win, and Disrupt.”

Written by Ernie Audino Senior Military Fellow, Gold Institute for International Strategy

2026 Ten-Point Forecast: NE-2 (U.S. House – Decisive)

Cover image for Seth Keshel's NE-2 House forecast

Brinker Harding (R) vs. Denise Powell (D)

I. The Race

The NE-2 candidates, Brinker Harding and Denise Powell

Brinker Harding (Republican) emerged from the GOP primary as the nominee looking to replace Don Bacon, who is retiring from Congress after five terms. Harding has spent most of the last decade as a member of the Omaha City Council.

Denise Powell (Democrat) has never run for office before. Her campaign revolves around her radical feminism (she co-founded a PAC called “Women Who Run Nebraska”), supposed outsider appeal, and her promises to stick it to Trump.

II. District Geography

Map of Nebraska's 2nd Congressional District

Nebraska’s 2nd Congressional District (NE-2) is a Republican Party catastrophe of its own making. President Trump carried the state, which has just three U.S. House districts, by 20.5%, yet lost the split electoral vote of NE-2 by 4.6%. The district consists of all of Douglas County (metro Omaha), a portion of Sarpy County, and all of Saunders County, which to the west of both. The idiotic Republican leadership in Nebraska’s unicameral legislature took the opportunity to redraw this seat ahead of the 2022 midterms, and instead of playing to win, added only a county (Saunders) that had less than 13,000 votes tallied in 2020 instead of shifting precincts around in Omaha.

Could they have figured out a creative way to ensure Republicans can cruise to victory in all three seats in a Trump +20 state? You tell me:

Map of Nebraska's three congressional districts

Sarpy is conservative, but becoming more suburbanized and losing margin. Saunders is super-MAGA, but small. Omaha, while not a monstrosity of a liberal city, is drifting leftward along with most major metros in America (including in the suburbs) and is reminding me a lot of KS-3, which Republicans lost in the 2018 wave.

Presidential Margins

2016 Trump +2.2%

2020 Biden +6.5%

2024 Harris +4.6%

Key Statistics

67.8% White, 12.8% Hispanic, 9.8% Black

97.9% Urban, 2.1% Rural

III. Market Assessment

Polymarket bettors, sniffing polls and presidential baselines, don’t think Brinker Harding has a chance.

IV. History

The district has represented Omaha since 1883; Republicans took the seat in 1994 and held it for 20 years, strangely losing it in 2014 (despite a red wave in which the GOP only lost one other seat) because Lee Terry blundered his way into a primary he barely won and lost the seat to Democrat Brad Ashford. Ashford won the seat with a 49% plurality thanks to a spoiler libertarian candidate exploiting the GOP feuding.

In 2016, retired Air Force Brigadier General Don Bacon won the Republican nomination and challenged Ashford for the seat. Bacon, an avowed Trump hater who now spends most of his days trashing Republicans on X, managed to knock off Ashford by an eyelash.

Result of the 2016 NE-2 House race, Bacon vs. Ashford

Bacon has managed to thread the needle four more times in an increasingly difficult district:

2018 +2.0%

2020 +4.6%

2022 +2.7%

2024 +1.9%

Five consecutive wins of the district for Bacon, and not a single one exceeding 4.6%. Trump outran Bacon’s 2016 margin by one point, so the above figures, with Bacon running 11.1% ahead of Trump in 2020 and 6.5% in 2024, truly demonstrate how much metro Omaha has drifted left in the past decade. Bacon did manage to win in 2018 by a higher margin than he posted in 2016, and almost directly in line with the 2016 presidential margin.

Bacon is now out, and leaves a difficult district for a GOP candidate with very little name recognition and a shattered coalition of voters.

V. Analysis of 2026 Primary Results

Harding ran unopposed in the Republican primary. Powell had to navigate a crowded field, and eventually prevailed over state legislator John Cavanaugh in a toxic battle:

2026 NE-2 Democratic primary results

Powell is the candidate who has to mend fences, but the rift isn’t as severe as can be observed in states that saw DSA-linked candidates battling establishment Democrats.

VI. Polls

I found one poll archived by The New York Times, and it shows Powell +4.

NE-2 poll showing Powell +4

VII. Media Ratings

Media ratings for the NE-2 race

All four major reviewing bodies have the race favorable to Powell, ranging from “tilt” to “likely.” “Likely” probably overstates her advantage.

VIII. Party Registration

NE-2 party registration change since the 2024 election

Since the 2024 election, NE-2 has inched slightly leftward – down 615 net registrations for Republicans and one-fifth of a point. This number generally tacks with the shifting of independent voters in presidential races, and the shift certainly doesn’t aid Harding’s cause.

IX. Election Considerations

Nebraska finally got with the program on Voter ID, and doesn’t operate Automatic Voter Registration or run mass mail-in elections. Manipulation is always possible with elections and has been identified in Nebraska, but this elections ranks low relative to others with regard to election integrity.

X. Summary and Election Estimate

Powell has three key factors in her favor:

• Money. Her figures compared to Harding’s at the end of June didn’t give her much of an advantage, but she isn’t being swamped by GOP funding like Democrat candidates have been in other seats.
• The open seat and the suburban drift give her a big boost. Douglas County and, by extension, NE-2 remind me of KS-3, which Kevin Yoder lost to Sharice Davids in 2018. That seat hasn’t returned to the Republicans and gives no indication it will anytime soon.
• Party registration figures reflect the continuing slide, and Harding lacks the big profile, status as a retired general, and party unity to make up the difference in a difficult year – especially given that Bacon never carried the seat by more than 4.6%.

Still, we run the actual elections for a reason. Turnout matters, and if the district’s black vote (roughly one-tenth of the electorate) doesn’t turn out, the Hispanic vote runs right, and suburbanites don’t run left out of concern for the future of the Democrats (unlikely in NE-2), then Harding has a chance. I see the key factors like this:

Seth Keshel's key factors table for the NE-2 race

Democrats are right to be bullish on a flip. While I don’t think NE-2 has a high ceiling for Democrats, Powell appears on the verge of taking the seat the Nebraska GOP refused to shore up.

Forecast for NE-2 House

Seth Keshel's forecast for the NE-2 House race

Seth Keshel, MBA is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy and a retired Army Captain. He publishes Captain K’s Corner on Substack.

2026 Ten-Point Forecast: NY-17 (U.S. House – Decisive)

NY-17 candidates Mike Lawler and Cait Conley

Mike Lawler (R-inc.) vs. Cait Conley (D)

I. The Race

NY-17 candidates Mike Lawler and Cait Conley

Mike Lawler (Republican) is seeking his third term and is one of just three Republicans in the House from a district President Trump lost in 2024. He has a proven record of running and winning in a tough district and is thought of as one of the more skilled politicians in Congress.

Cait Conley (Democrat) is new to campaigning, although she played a big role in CISA’s 2024 election monitoring operations. Prior to working at CISA, she had a long career as an Army officer.

II. District Geography

Map of New York's 17th Congressional District

New York’s 17th Congressional District (NY-17) is located in the Hudson Valley not far north of New York City. It contains all of Rockland and Putnam Counties, as well as the extremely dense northern portion of Westchester County and a small portion of southern Dutchess County. Rockland is a competitive county, Putnam is very red, and Westchester County is a Democrat stronghold. The variance in these counties requires candidates to be flexible on ideology and fast to react to changes in public mood.

This district contains some of the most interesting electoral factoids I’ve encountered in my analysis of the 2026 races, which I will analyze in detail in the summary of this forecast. Until recently, it has been noticeably out of reach for President Trump. That changed in 2024 with his improvements with minorities, religious groups, and in the urban and suburban areas of the northeast.

Presidential Margins

Presidential margins in NY-17

Harris wound up winning NY-17, but just barely at a +0.4% margin of victory. This marked a substantial improvement for Trump, who dropped it by 8.0% in 2016 and 10.0% in 2020, mail-in election and all. Similar shifts in margin in the 2024 presidential elections can be seen in adjacent spaces such as eastern Pennsylvania, throughout New Jersey, and in New York City itself. Lee Zeldin carried the district by four points in his 2022 gubernatorial bid.

Key Statistics

64.4% White, 19.9% Hispanic, 7.1% Black, 5.0% Asian

98.4% Urban, 1.6% Rural

III. Market Assessment

Conley, like most Democrats in decisive races, is favored on Polymarket – but not by a lot. That is an indicator of the competitive nature of this seat and Lawler’s quality as a candidate.

IV. History

Here in the beginning of the 21st century, NY-17 has remained consistently defined, with only slight variations. In elections held from 2002 through 2010, the seat includes parts of the Bronx, Rockland County, and Westchester County. From 2012 through 2020, races covered Rockland and a larger portion of Westchester. Democrats Eliot Engel, Nita Lowey, and Mondaire Jones held the seat.

As soon as the seat was redrawn to add Putnam County and the small piece of Dutchess, Mike Lawler won the seat. Here is his razor close result from 2022:

2022 NY-17 result, Lawler's win

Impressively, running for reelection in a district Biden had carried by 10 points just four years earlier, Lawler put some serious distance between himself and Mondaire Jones, who had held the seat in a previous form but lost the nomination to face Lawler in 2022.

2024 NY-17 result, Lawler over Mondaire Jones

V. Analysis of 2026 Primary Results

Lawler faced no primary challenge; Conley did, and won the election with just short of a majority:

2026 NY-17 Democrat primary results

There is no evidence the rest of the field that participated in the Democrat primary poses a risk to the General Election, as all have gotten behind the Conley campaign.

VI. Polls

Polling data from The New York Times:

Recent polls of the NY-17 race

Tossing the 5-point outlier (pro-Lawler), we have polling suggesting a dead heat/statistical tie. Enough for me to buy that this is a close race without a clear favorite.

VII. Media Ratings

Media race ratings for NY-17

All major reviewing bodies lack the fortitude to make a call on this race as it stands. A positive sign for Lawler in a fundamentally tough district.

VIII. Party Registration

NY-17 party registration changes

New York hasn’t updated its voter registration data in a while, but things are moving the right direction for Lawler – unlike how the registration data are moving against Tom Kean in NJ-7.

While this isn’t enough (like in a presidential election) to form a concrete prediction, it is yet another data point suggesting NY-17 isn’t the automatic flip that blue wave advocates surmise it to be.

IX. Election Considerations

I reviewed New York’s 2024 election, which featured a sharp shift in favor of Trump everywhere, in December 2024, in New York – 2024 Election Compendium.

New York has a mixed bag of election laws. They do have Automatic Voter Registration, and also don’t require Voter ID, but the biggest threat to statewide election integrity has to do with transparency. On December 3, 2024, nearly a full month after Election Day, New York tabulated a massive ballot drop that went like this:

New York's December 3, 2024 ballot drop

That drop had Harris with over three-quarters of the vote, a margin higher than she obtained overall within New York City’s five boroughs. Needless to say, with this sort of leeway, population dense areas have extra power to inflict maximum damage in the event of a close race. Think Westchester County in the battle for NY-17.

X. Summary and Election Estimate

Lawler’s methodology for carrying the district is simple. Knock it out of the park in the red turf present in Rockland, Putnam, and Dutchess Counties, and hold the line in Westchester. Lawler lost the 273 precincts of Westchester County that are part of NY-17 by 12 points (approximately 55% to 43%). Trump lost them by 20.3% (59.9% to 39.6%). Despite the lopsided margin, Trump improved in the Westchester portion by 7.4% over 2020.

Captain K proprietary precinct map of NY-17
Captain K Proprietary Mapping of NY-17

What most don’t understand about this district is that it possesses the most overwhelmingly MAGA vote in the United States – even more crimson-shaded than the reddest areas of the Texas Panhandle or the most rural areas of Wyoming or Idaho. Let’s take a closer look at the crimson precincts in the heart of Rockland County:

Precinct map of central Rockland County

By my count, there are 11 precincts in the Ramapo area in which Trump won over 95% of 500 or more votes (28 total precincts with Trump at over 95% of the vote). Here’s one example:

Ramapo 55
Trump 987
Harris 1
Other 0
Margin – Trump +99.8%

Trump had a similar margin there, and in the others, in 2020, but in 2016, the same precinct looked like this:

Trump 42
Clinton 657
Other 1
Margin – Clinton +87.9%

By now, I hope you understand why it is you subscribe to Captain K’s Corner – because you won’t find this level of detail anywhere else. Here’s why this is important to 2026:

Lawler is going to own this vote (and he won it by almost identical margins to Trump’s in 2024). He and Speaker Mike Johnson have been all over those precincts and courting the Orthodox/Hasidic Jewish bloc vote. Unlike the scattered voters of the remaining areas of NY-17, this group will absolutely vote, and they will vote for Lawler. The purpose of me pointing this out is not to advocate for any position in the ongoing debates over Zionism; it is to simply tell you that the people who provide the boost for Lawler are almost certainly to discern the emergence of the DSA faction of the Democrat Party as a clear and present threat to their political worldview, and side en masse with Lawler. Trump’s margin in those 28 precincts in which he got over 95 percent of the vote came out to this:

Trump 13,217
Harris 176
Other 30
Margin – Trump +97.2%

Lawler will then take those margins and do the Susan Collins routine to prevent getting blown out in Westchester, and put himself in position to hold his seat. I see the key factors of the race like this:

Key factors in the NY-17 race

With Lawler’s resilience in Westchester County and strategic efforts to secure the Orthodox vote (which will vote in large numbers and as directed by their rabbis), I consider him the favorite in this race, even if only by a hair:

Forecast for the NY-17 U.S. House race

I think Westchester will swing, but I also think the turnout of enthusiastic Trump/Lawler supporters in Rockland County will balance this impact; He won’t win the race by 6 points, but he has some margin to give and Conley is the candidate lacking a major bloc vote. She can definitely win the race, but has serious structural challenges to account for.

Seth Keshel, MBA is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy and a retired Army Captain. He publishes Captain K’s Corner on Substack.

2026 Ten-Point Forecast: PA-8 (U.S. House – Decisive)

2026 Ten-Point Forecast: PA-8, Rob Bresnahan vs. Paige Cognetti

Rob Bresnahan (R-inc.) vs. Paige Cognetti (D)

I. The Race

PA-8 candidates Rob Bresnahan and Paige Cognetti

Rob Bresnahan (Republican), having taken the seat from Democrat incumbent Matt Cartwright by 1.6% in 2024, seeks a second term. He is defending what is by far the most favorable of three decisive seats this year for Republicans.

Paige Cognetti (Democrat) is the mayor of Scranton and is running on the standard Democrat “healthcare” platform and promising to bring transparency and anti-corruption measures to Washington. She is attempting this despite a major surge for President Trump in northeastern Pennsylvania in the last election.

II. District Geography

Map of Pennsylvania's 8th Congressional District

Pennsylvania’s 8th Congressional District (PA-8) is wedged into the far northeastern corner of the Keystone State, and is right across the Delaware River from another decisive seat, NJ-7. It contains all of Wayne, Pike, and Lackawanna Counties, as well as a portion of Luzerne County and most of Monroe County. Four of those five counties were won by Trump in the 2024 election, and the district’s sharp rightward movement played a huge role in the recapture of Pennsylvania’s 19 electoral votes.

This is a huge working-class area that has shifted heavily toward the Republican Party in the age of Trump primarily over the issue of trade. Obama carried the dirt making up the present district by double digits in both of his runs, and even including a left lurch for “Scranton Joe” in 2020 due to the mail-in balloting fiasco, Trump carried it in all three of his runs – with his most impressive mark in 2024:

Presidential Margins

Presidential margins in PA-8

While the district is mostly made up of Trump’s bread-and-butter demographic, the white working class, over one-eighth of the population is Hispanic. Trump’s major gains with the Hispanic voter base helped propel Bresnahan to his 2024 victory over a tough Democrat incumbent.

Key Statistics

74.6% White, 13.2% Hispanic, 6.3% Black

III. Market Assessment

Polymarket bettors have over-valued Cognetti, giving her a 73% shot at victory.

IV. History

In 2016, much of the turf represented in today’s PA-8 was part of the old PA-10, including a lot of the bedrock northern Pennsylvania red wall. Tom Marino (Republican) won the seat by over 40 points against his Democrat opponent.

In 2018, courts ordered an entirely new map in the Keystone State ahead of midterms. The northeastern corner became PA-8, and the boundaries of the elections held in 2018 and 2020 closely match those in use today, with only minor changes in Luzerne and Monroe Counties. Matt Cartwright, who had been in Congress since 2013 representing the old PA-17 (which included Scranton), moved over to the new race in the fresh PA-8, and took care of business in the 2018 House wave:

2018 PA-8 result, Matt Cartwright's win

He was reelected in 2020, alongside a Trump +3 margin in the district, by 3.6%, and held on as the GOP flipped the House majority in 2022 by 2.4%, though holding the seat in either race have been highly unlikely without the changes imposed by Act 77 (2019), which allowed for no-excuse mail-in voting throughout the state.

Stuck in increasingly reddening turf and facing a Trump surge in the region, Cartwright finally lost the seat in 2024 to the man defending it this year (Bresnahan):

2024 PA-8 result, Bresnahan over Cartwright

It is widely believed that Bresnahan would have won a much more comfortable margin had he not been squaring off against Cartwright.

V. Analysis of 2026 Primary Results

Neither Bresnahan nor Cognetti faced a primary opponent, so there is no anticipation of party feuding or drama that will impact the November outcome.

VI. Polls

Poll listings pulled from The New York Times:

Recent polls of the PA-8 race

Two virtual ties in polls ordered by Democrat sponsors provide no visible edge for Cognetti.

VII. Media Ratings

Media race ratings for PA-8

Since summer, two of these reviewing bodies have downgraded the race from “Lean Republican” to toss-up. No one at this stage in the game is willing to take a leap of faith one way or another.

VIII. Party Registration

Party registration in the five PA-8 counties

The figures above are imprecise and represent the voter registration figures of the five counties of PA-8 in full (not accounting for partial counties of Luzerne and Monroe); however, all five have become more Republican (Luzerne, Pike, and Wayne) or less Democrat (Lackawanna and Monroe) since Trump won the district big in 2024.

• Lackawanna from D+26,902 to D+24,722
• Luzerne from R+2,688 to R+4,746
• Monroe from D+7,606 to D+5,495
• Pike from R+8,710 to R+9,468
• Wayne from R+12,668 to R+13,011

Cognetti needs all she can squeeze out of Lackawanna and Monroe Counties, and neither are moving in her party’s direction. The continued Republican trend of this area is a huge boost for Bresnahan, even if these figures are more predictive of presidential trend than they are applicable to midterm analysis.

IX. Election Considerations

Read my book, The American War on Election Corruption, if you’d like to understand the major impacts to Pennsylvania’s elections caused by the introduction of mass mail-in voting. It’s not crackpot stuff; Pennsylvania’s elections are now more about ballot collection than they are about vote getting. The registration numbers shown above suggest Democrats, particularly with the area stagnant in population growth, should be incapable of gaining votes cycle after cycle, but they still manage to compete.

Pennsylvania has some of the worst elections in America. Read my 2024 election compendium, Pennsylvania – 2024 Election Compendium (December 21, 2024), to understand the stakes and why this is a potentially huge boost for Cognetti if the race is tight.

X. Summary and Election Estimate

I get people asking me all the time if I think Josh Shapiro can be beaten this year in the gubernatorial race. I don’t think there is a snowball’s chance in hell of that happening. The risk of a massive landslide is that the three key Republican defenses in the state (PA-7, PA-8, and PA-10) get buried for lack of GOP intensity. PA-8, Bresnahan’s seat, is by far the most likely of those seats to be successfully defended. If he can hold the seat, Republicans have a very good shot of a photo finish for the House majority.

Bresnahan has considerable strength in a working-class district not commonly associated with GOP candidates. He has the standard conservative endorsements, such as that of the NRA and many law enforcement organizations, but his most vital endorsements are these:

• Pennsylvania Conference of Teamsters
• American Federation of Government Employees
• Brotherhood of Railroad Signalmen
• Many other labor unions too numerous to list

Understanding why those backers are important requires you to understand the electoral terrain:

Captain K proprietary precinct map of PA-8
Captain K Proprietary Mapping of PA-8

Wayne and Pike Counties are traditional Pennsylvania GOP strongholds. Wayne hasn’t backed a Democrat for president since 1892, while Pike has only backed three in the past century (and none since 1964). Those have been red, and only got redder under Trump. The key to the Trumpian revolution in Pennsylvania ran through counties like Luzerne and Monroe. Luzerne aligned with the winner of Pennsylvania’s electoral votes in every election from 1936 through 2016 (missed in 2020 because of the mail-induced quasi election), and Monroe is emerging as a new blue-collar bellwether along with Erie and Northampton Counties.

Lackawanna is where Cognetti is going to have to hit it big, and its Democrat strength has also waned. Obama beat Romney there by 27.2% in 2012, and Trump only missed the mark by 2.8% in 2024. If Bresnahan is going to ride the red counties to huge margins and have appeal to the Trumpy Monroe and Luzerne Counties, these blue collar endorsements will help him minimize the impact of Lackawanna for Cognetti (which she will win).

Here is where things stand today with regard to the key factors of the race:

Key factors in the PA-8 race

Forecast for PA-8 House

Forecast for the PA-8 U.S. House race

While campaigning for Congress, Bresnahan railed against members trading stocks; he has since become one of the most prolific traders in all of Congress, and Cognetti has made that a key issue of her anti-corruption crusade – essentially accusing him of insider trading. Still, Bresnahan knows the path to victory in PA-8 relies on him sticking to the trade-based platform that has earned him his blue-collar endorsements, and I think this seat tilts his way ever so slightly in what is a must-win for the Republicans.

Seth Keshel, MBA is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy and a retired Army Captain. He publishes Captain K’s Corner on Substack.

2026 Ten-Point Forecast: NC-11 (U.S. House – Decisive)

2026 Ten-Point Forecast: NC-11, Jennifer Balkcom vs. Jamie Ager

Jennifer Balkcom (R) vs. Jamie Ager (D)

I. The Race

NC-11 candidates Jennifer Balkcom and Jamie Ager

Jennifer Balkcom (Republican) was selected by the Executive Committee of the NC-11 Republican Party to run as GOP nominee. This pick happened after the primary, and was required after incumbent Chuck Edwards decided he didn’t want to run again when it became clear he was going to be roasted over an ethics investigation into inappropriate workplace conduct with female staffers. Balkcom has served two terms in the North Carolina House of Representatives and is faced with a major burden of starting from scratch with less than 90 days to run the campaign.

Jamie Ager (Democrat) is one of the best Democrat candidates in the United States and is attempting to revive a brand of “mountain Democrat” that is practically extinct. He’s 47, a farmer, and the CEO of Hickory Nut Gap Farms in Fairview, North Carolina. His reported net worth is nearly $19 million.

II. District Geography

Map of North Carolina's 11th Congressional District

North Carolina’s 11th Congressional District (NC-11) is the westernmost district in the state. It hugs most of the state’s boundary with Tennessee and also borders South Carolina and Georgia. Asheville, a steadily growing leftist stronghold, is fully contained within the district, which is still dealing with the flood-related impacts of Hurricane Helene two years later.

President Trump carried the district, as it is presently drawn, all three times he ran – but by declining margins each time.

Presidential Margins

Presidential margins in NC-11

This decline in margin comes from much of the district being “maxed out,” meaning small counties with stagnant populations are no longer able to produce larger margins, and the expansion of Buncombe County (Asheville):

Buncombe County presidential results, 2016 to 2024

Whereas Trump lost Buncombe by 14.2%, a margin of 19,736 votes, in 2016, he lost it by 24.7% and 39,646 votes in 2024. There has also been a decline in GOP margin in mid-sized counties, such as Henderson, which Josh Stein carried against Mark Robinson in the 2024 gubernatorial race:

Henderson County results, 2016 to 2024

While it was worth +15,982 margin for Trump in 2016, it only gave him +10,136 in 2024. The North Carolina legislature would be wise to reassess these boundaries and split Asheville in two the next time they address the maps.

Key Statistics

82.3% White, 7.7% Hispanic

III. Market Assessment

Polymarket bettors understate Jennifer Balkcom’s position based on partisan strength alone, but accurately assess the risk of an Ager victory.

IV. History

NC-11 has a “blue dog” Democrat representing it in its recent history – former NFL quarterback Heath Shuler. Shuler fashioned himself as a conservative Democrat and was elected in the 2006 wave, then reelected twice. After his final reelection in 2010, the North Carolina House redrew the districts and cut away much of Asheville. Shuler read the room and retired from Congress.

Then came Mark Meadows, who was elected in 2012 and re-elected three times before resigning the seat to become President Trump’s Chief of Staff in 2020, as the COVID-19 fracas was underway. With the seat open, Madison Cawthorn prevailed in the GOP primary and won the seat at the age of 25, with President Trump on the ticket:

2020 NC-11 result, Madison Cawthorn's win

Cawthorn ran roughly even with Trump in the district (as it was drawn then), then proceeded to damage his reputation in Congress with careless behavior. Chuck Edwards exploited this and railed against Cawthorn’s morality, and ousted him in the 2022 GOP primary:

2022 NC-11 GOP primary, Edwards over Cawthorn

Edwards beat Democrat Jasmine Beach-Ferrara by 9.3% in the 2022 General Election, then cruised to reelection in 2024, outrunning Trump by 4.1% on the same ticket and in the same dirt:

2024 NC-11 result, Edwards' reelection

All is well, right? A district with slight, but steady, leftward drift in a battleground state, but with a secure GOP incumbent that can win by more than 13 points?

Too bad Edwards couldn’t internalize all the admonishment he dished out to Cawthorn. Rather than buckling down on the work, he essentially wrote the “how to” guide for workplace harassment and generally making his staffers feel creeped out. The ethics investigation timeline didn’t drag out long enough to save Edwards’s campaign, so he dropped out of the race shortly after winning the primary.

And here we are, having to defend a relatively safe Republican seat in a midterm with little margin for error.

V. Analysis of 2026 Primary Results

Edwards won his primary by more than 40 points, but that is now a moot point. Ager won his primary convincingly, also:

2026 NC-11 Democrat primary results

There are no signs of drama post-primary for Democrats, although Ager’s “blue dog” vibes will irritate radical leftists in Asheville; however, with an opportunity to win the seat, they’ll hold their noses and vote for him, especially with no Green candidate on the ballot.

Edwards’s departure and replacement by a candidate with a small online footprint and low name ID is the bigger story, and the late adjustment to this race is a major windfall for Democrats.

VI. Polls

I pulled the only poll I could find from The New York Times:

Poll of the NC-11 race

A Democrat sponsor found the race at Ager +3, well short of a majority and generally inconclusive – as most polls are these days.

VII. Media Ratings

Media race ratings for NC-11

Only one of these analytical tanks still has the race favoring Balkcom, down from three a month ago. Still, no one is quite ready to lean it for Ager.

VIII. Party Registration

NC-11 party registration changes since November 2024

Despite a Democrat statewide surge in registrations since summer, NC-11 is notably more Republican than it was in November 2024. Democrats have lost over 2,500 registrants in Buncombe County since then, and the district itself sits over 7,000 registrations right from two years ago. This is not enough to seal the deal for Balkcom, but it makes the pathway to victory that much more difficult for Ager.

IX. Election Considerations

North Carolina only recently passed Voter ID, and has reasonably basic safeguards in place. It is not extremely easy to cheat in the state (exempting the mail-in heavy 2020 quasi election), but loopholes exist in the event of a close election, like that for the Supreme Court in 2024 – when the Democrat candidate “won” by 734 ballots after weeks of UOCAVA and provisional ballot drips.

In NC-11 specifically, based on disrupted registration to margin trends not seen in other portions of the state, I do believe absentee ballot cheating happened in small numbers in 2024 – but not enough to flip the state. Loopholes were available in Hurricane-impacted counties post-Helene, and my numbers suggest they were somewhat exploited. Those will not be open for exploitation in 2026, so the electoral environment isn’t of great concern to me this year.

You can read more about the above concerns in my review, North Carolina – 2024 Election Compendium (December 3, 2024).

X. Summary and Election Estimate

This seat becoming a decisive race for 2026 comes down to sheer Republican unforced error. It falls into the same category as OH-7, now a decisive race because Max Miller didn’t advise anyone of looming personal drama that was going to exacerbate the natural out-party margin advantage in a midterm year.

Edwards knew the ethics investigation was coming after him. He gambled and figured that anything that may drop on him would come after the November election, which he would have won against Ager somewhere in the mid to high single digits, riding incumbency. Had he prioritized the majority rather than his own status, he could have declined to run for reelection well in advance of the primary.

As things stand now, Balkcom has had to start from scratch. She won her own primary to run for reelection to the State House just two months ago, and now she’s taking on one of the most well-funded Democrats who actually fits his district in a year in which Democrats are blowing winnable races by nominating DSA-aligned radicals. She is being trounced in fundraising, and any leftward swinging that would have occurred against Edwards naturally (the swing in the former NC-11 was 7.8% left in 2018) will be amplified with the seat open.

Up until recently, I’ve had NC-11 in my “GOP leaner” category, even with Edwards out of the picture. Based on the data I track for these projections, I’m left with no choice but to now place this race on the decisive list. Mathematical pathways exist to a majority without this seat, but losing such a fundamentally strong seat makes it an extremely uphill climb to hold the House.

Captain K proprietary precinct map of NC-11
Captain K Proprietary Mapping of NC-11

The mapping above highlights the challenging electoral terrain in a race like this. Ager will get a big margin from Buncombe County (Asheville), which has a lot more high-propensity white liberals as a percentage voting in it than your standard urban area, such as Charlotte, which may see a drag with minority turnout once in-person early voting picks up. Those yellow precincts you see above (all over Henderson County), are precincts Trump won in 2024 that had notable leftward drift in margin from 2020, and in some cases, all the way back to 2016. These are the types of precincts Democrat Governor Josh Stein won in carrying this district by 7 points in his race against Mark Robinson (concurrent with the presidential race won by Trump by 9.2%).

Here is where things stand today with regard to the key factors of the race:

Key factors in the NC-11 race

Forecast for NC-11 House

Forecast for the NC-11 U.S. House race

As noted earlier, Josh Stein won NC-11 by 7 points against Mark Robinson. North Carolina plays strange ball with Democrats in statewide elections, but has a very clear Republican preference for federal races. The big question for both Ager and Balkcom comes down to which preference will take root in this race. Edwards, free of scandal, would have carried this seat easily – albeit by a reduced margin from 2024. Balkcom, brand new to the race and facing a very tough midterm opponent with strong local ties and money, is a flip of the coin. A 55/45 rating in my system is a dead heat, and since I don’t believe in leaving things tied, she only holds an advantage based on the electoral terrain of the district and its modern precedent for electing Republicans. I don’t think either candidate has a ceiling of more than a few points in what may be one of the closest races this fall.

This seat has no business being in play, and you can thank Chuck Edwards if it is lost.

Seth Keshel, MBA is a Senior Fellow at the Gold Institute for International Strategy and a retired Army Captain. He publishes Captain K’s Corner on Substack.